Skip to main content
editorial
. 2011 Mar 9;28(4):291–301. doi: 10.1007/s10815-011-9552-6

Table 1.

The advantages and disadvantages of different reprogramming methods for induction of pluripotent stem cells

Methods Type Subtypes Advantages or disadvantages
Gene delivery methods Viral delivery system Lentivirus Advantages
- Infect both dividing and non-dividing cells
- Recombinant can be pseudotyped to broaden tropism
- Highly efficient
- Constitutive and inducible expression can be attained
Disadvantage
- Integration into host genome
Retrovirus Advantages
- Undergo silencing in ES cells
- Highly efficient
Disadvantage
- Integration into host genome
Adenovirus Advantage
- Non-integrating vector
Disadvantages
- Poor gene transfer
- Control of gene expression level difficult
Non-viral system Episomal plasmids Advantages
- Non-integrating vector
- Able to replicate autonomously giving rise to prolonged expression
Disadvantage
- Low reprogramming efficiency
Excision strategies Cre-loxP recombination Advantages
- Gene expression profile closer to hES cells compared to human iPS cells
- Efficient excision of integrated transgenes
Disadvantages
- Genomic instability and genome rearrangements
- loxP site remain integrated in genome
piggyBac transposon Advantages
- Self-excision
- Precise and efficient excision
Disadvantage
- pBt gene may remain active post-transposition
Non-DNA methods Protein-mediated Poly-arginine peptide tags Advantages
- Reprogrammed cells from embryonic fibroblast cells were indistinguishable from the classic embryonic stem cells
Disadvantages
- Not clear is can be used for adult cells
- Short half-life
Manipulation of cell-culture conditions Oxygen level manipulation Advantages
- No genetic manipulation
- No protein carriers needed
Disadvantage
- Short-term induction
miRNAs miR-294, miR-302 Advantages
- Able to replace c-Myc
- Increased efficiency
Disadvantages
- Not specific
- Target point may be too upstream in the cell signalling pathway
- Expression not easily controlled post-induction
Enhancing DNA reprogramming efficiencies Small molecules and soluble factors Chromatin modification modifiers Advantages
- Modulate chromatin modification
- Target cell-signalling pathways
Disadvantage
- Non-specific and broad action
- May cause dysregulation of gene expression