Table 2.

Prevalence and concordance of alcohol use disorders (AUD) at different thresholds in the Emergency Room Collaborative Alcohol Analysis Project (ERCAAP)

	Total Sample	Current Drinkers	Kappa w/AUD (current drinkers)*	% of those with DSM-IV Abuse classified with new diagnosis	% of those with DSM-IV Dep. classified with new diagnosis	% of those NON-DSM-IV Dep. classified with new diagnosis
Proposed DSM-V 11 criteria, without legal, add craving
1 or more	20.5	33.3	0.68	99.5%	100.0%	14.5%
2 or more	12.8	20.9	0.80	65.6%	100.0%	6.3%
3 or more	9.3	15.1	0.79	36.6%	100.0%	2.4%
4 or more	7.3	11.8	0.68	14.1%	92.1%	0.9%
5 or more	5.8	9.5	0.58	2.1%	81.1%	0.1%

^*Kappa is for the concordance between any alcohol abuse or dependence in the DSM-IV and the threshold using the proposed 11 criteria for DSM-V