Table 2. Descriptions of influenza outbreaksa that have carried the “pandemic” label.
Year | Virus | Nickname | Descriptions |
---|---|---|---|
1918 | H1N1 | Spanish flu | “devastating pandemic” (US CDC)40 |
“severe” (US CDC)41 | |||
“exceptional” (WHO)42 | |||
1957 | H2N2 | Asian flu | “comparatively mild” (WHO)42 |
“substantial pandemic” (WHO)17 | |||
“severe” (US CDC)41 | |||
“moderate” (US HHS)43 | |||
1968 | H3N2 | Hong Kong flu | “moderate” (US CDC)41 |
“huge economic and social disruption” (UK DoH)44 | |||
“mild” (WHO)45 | |||
“substantial pandemic” (WHO)17 | |||
“Few people who lived through it even knew it occurred.” (John Barry)46 | |||
1977 | H1N1 | Russian flu | “mild” (US CDC)41 |
“benign pandemic” (WHO)17 | |||
2009 | H1N1 | Swine flu | “moderate” (WHO)5,47 |
“largely reassuring clinical picture” (WHO)48 |
US CDC, United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; UK DoH, United Kingdom Department of Health; US HHS, United States Department of Health and Human Services; WHO, World Health Organization.
a Whether it is called an outbreak, epidemic, or pandemic, influenza has a cyclic propensity to capture the world’s attention and to generate large public health responses. However, with the exception of the 1918 pandemic, which all agree was catastrophically severe, the impact of more recent outbreaks carrying the “pandemic” label is difficult to gauge, as their divergent descriptions suggest.