Table 3.
Lower limb biomechanical analyses, gait characteristics and footwear conditions of included studies
| Study | Biomechanical variable(s) | Gait characteristics | Footwear condition(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Azevedo et al. [27] | Muscle activity (integrated EMG: normalised EMG amplitude as a percentage of root mean square amplitude): tibialis anterior, peroneus longus, lateral gastrocnemius, rectus femoris, biceps femoris and gluteus medius; Kinematics (3D using Vicon® System 370 Version 2.5): sagittal plane hip, knee and ankle joints; Kinetics: anterior-posterior and vertical ground reaction force; Temporospatial parameters (speed, stride length, stride time, stride frequency). |
Running Uv, Og |
C (neutral running shoe) |
| Baur et al. [11] | Muscle activity (normalised EMG amplitude to mean amplitude of the entire gait cycle and timing of activity): tibialis anterior, peroneals, lateral head of gastrocnemius, medial head of gastrocnemius, soleus; Kinetics: antero-posterior and vertical ground reaction force; Plantar pressures (Novel Pedar® Mobile system): deviation of the centre of pressure. |
Running Cv (12 km/hour), Tm |
C (gymnastic shoe that simulates barefoot conditions) and C (standardised marketed reference running shoe |
| Donoghue et al. [33] | Kinematics (3D: functional data analysis using 3D Qualysis system with Peak Motus™ analysis system): frontal plane rearfoot and lower leg, sagittal plane ankle and knee joints. | Running Cv (~2.8 m/s), Tm |
U (own running shoes) |
| Donoghue et al. [34] | Kinematics (3D Qualysis system with Peak Motus™ analysis system): frontal plane rearfoot and lower leg, sagittal plane ankle and knee joints. | Running Cv (~2.5-2.8 ± 0.2-0.4 m/s), Tm |
Unable to determine (as type of footwear not specified) and B |
| Kaufman et al. [19] | Plantar pressures (Tekscan® in-shoe system): dynamic arch index. | Running Uv, Og |
C (military footwear) and B |
| McCrory et al. [25] | Kinematics (2D Motion Analysis high-speed video camera): frontal plane rearfoot. Kinetics: antero-posterior, medio-lateral and vertical ground reaction forces. |
Running Uv ('training pace'), T (kinematics), Og (kinetics) |
U (own footwear) |
| Ryan et al. [35] | Kinematics (3D ViconPeak® system with Bodybuilder 3.6® software): frontal and sagittal plane rearfoot and transverse plane tibia. | Running Uv, Og |
B |
| Van Ginckel et al. [2] | Plantar pressures (RsScan Footscan® pressure plate): multiple variables (temporal data, peak force, force-time integrals, contact time, medio-lateral force ratios and position and deviation of the centre of force). | Running Uv, Og |
B |
| Williams et al. [24] | Kinematics and moments (3D Qualisys motion system with Visual 3-D software): transverse plane tibia relative to foot (tibial motion) and tibia relative to femur (knee motion). | Running Cv, Og (3.35 m/s ± 5%). |
B |
Abbreviations:
EMG, electromyography; 2D, two-dimensional analysis; 3D, three-dimensional analysis; Cv, controlled velocity; Uv, uncontrolled velocity; Og, overground; Tm, treadmill; C, yes and controlled; U, yes but uncontrolled; B, barefoot.