Table 3.
Outcome dimension(s) addressed | Studies | Evaluation design | Quality score | Effects | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Post survey | Follow up | ||||
knowledge | Halbach 2005 | pre/post survey, follow up | 8 | ↑ | ↑ |
Madigosky 2006 | pre/post survey, follow up | 8 | ↑ | ↑ | |
Moskowitz 2007 | pre/post survey | 6 | / | / | |
Patey 2009 | pre survey, follow up | 8 | / | ↑ | |
Paxton 2009 | pre/post survey | 6 | ↑ | / | |
Gunderson 2009 | pre/post survey | 6 | ↑ | / | |
skills | Halbach 2005 | pre/post survey, follow up | 8 | ↑ | ↑ |
Madigosky 2006 | pre/post survey, follow up | 8 | Some↑ Some→ |
Some↑ Some→ |
|
Moskowitz 2007 | pre/post survey | 6 | / | / | |
Anderson 2009 | pre/post survey | 10 | ↑ | / | |
Patey 2009 | pre survey, follow up | 8 | / | ↑ | |
Paxton 2009 | pre/post survey | 6 | ↑ | / | |
Gunderson 2009 | pre/post survey | 6 | ↑ | / | |
attitudes | Madigosky 2006 | pre/post survey, follow up | 8 | Some↑ Some→ Some* |
Some↑ Some→ Some* |
Moskowitz 2007 | pre/post survey | 6 | Some↑ Some→ |
/ | |
Patey 2009 | pre survey, follow up | 8 | / | → | |
Gunderson 2009 | pre/post survey | 6 | ↑ | / |
↑:improvement or changes in the expected direction
→:no effect or without change or not sustained
/:not report
*:changes in an undesired direction