TABLE 2.
Biomarkers | Serum folate | RBC folate | Serum unmetabolized folic acid | Plasma tHcy |
How useful is it for assessing exposure (intake)? | ++ | + | ++ | ++ |
Very sensitive to recent changes in intake but confounded by pregnancy, alcohol ingestion. Repetitive measurements over time may be necessary. | Not reflective of current intake but reflects longer term status and can be useful in conjunction with serum folate. Frequently low concentrations due to vitamin B-12 deficiency. | Quite reflective of current intake of fortified food/supplements but not of total folate | Good correlation with folate especially in nonelderly age groups | |
How useful is it for assessing status (short-, long-term)? | + | ++ | Not useful | ++ |
Not always low in folate deficiency, and low concentrations are not necessarily indicative of folate deficiency | Compromised sensitivity (normal concentrations in folate depletion) and specificity (low concentrations in vitamin B-12 deficiency) | Responds to treatment in days but may take longer to return to normal. Note: paradoxical small increase in tHcy shortly after dosing with folic acid reported. | ||
How useful is it for assessing function? | Probably not useful | Probably not useful | Under investigation | +++ |
Specific folate form (bioactive form) at the tissue level will affect function | Specific folate form (bioactive form) at the tissue level will affect function | Unclear whether serum unmetabolized folic acid plays a role in cancer development and/or promotion, immune response, etc | A functional indicator in the absence of confounders | |
Determinants or confounders (eg, age, sex, pregnancy, lactation, infection, polymorphisms)? | Age? | Age? | SNPs in DHFR? | Age |
Pregnancy | Vitamin B-12 | Sex | ||
Alcohol consumption | Pregnancy | Renal function | ||
Smoking | Alcohol consumption | Polymorphism: MTHFR | ||
Drug use interactions (antifolates) | Smoking | Other B vitamins: vitamins B-12, B-6, B-2 | ||
Thalassemia | Drug use interactions (antifolates) | |||
SNPs (MTHFR 677 C→T) | Thalassemia | |||
SNPs (MTHFR 677C→T) | ||||
Accepted cutoffs indicating deficient/normal/excess states? | Negative balance: serum folate <7 nmol/L (3 ng/mL) | Deficiency: RBC folate <305 nmol/L (140 ng/mL) | None | >12 μmol/L B vitamin deficiency/imbalance |
Subclinical deficiency: serum folate <10 nmol/L (increased Hcy) | Subclinical deficiency: RBC folate <340 nmol/L (increased Hcy) | ? lower for females, children | ||
Reduced risk of NTD-affected pregnancy: serum folate >16 nmol/L (7 ng/mL) | Reduced risk of NTD-affected pregnancy: 900 nmol/L (≈400 ng/mL) | |||
Other relevant issues: modifiers of validity (eg, infection) | Assay standardization | Assay standardization | Availability of standard reference materials with certified values for SFA (currently only reference value available) | Assay standardization |
Availability of standard reference materials with certified values for “total folate” | Availability of standard reference materials with certified values for “total folate” | |||
Population vs individual? | Both | Both | Probably both | Both |
Applicable in resource-constrained situations (eg, technical, sample storage, cost)? | Very limited | Very limited | No | Plasma preference |
Serum needs to be frozen within days of collection | Whole blood needs to be processed and frozen within days of collection | Requires chromatographic separation from other folate forms | Continued production of tHcy in erythrocytes and export into serum during clotting; keep EDTA whole blood chilled until processed (maximum: 4–6 h) | |
For long-term storage, it needs to be frozen < −40°C | Need to generate accurate hemolysate | |||
Microbiological assay offers accurate results at low cost, but manual handling required and has limited throughput | Need to determine hematocrit (and serum folate) | |||
Microbiological assay offers accurate results at low cost, but manual handling required and has limited throughput | ||||
Multiple biomarkers needed? | Yes (for unequivocal diagnosis of folate deficiency) | No (but serum folate is a plus) | No | Yes (for unequivocal diagnosis of folate deficiency) |
Other (clinical) information needed? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
RBC folate | Serum vitamin B-12 | Dietary intake | Renal function (creatinine) | |
Serum vitamin B-12 | Possibly serum folate | |||
Hematologic findings | Hematologic findings | |||
Dietary intake | Dietary intake |
RBC, red blood cell; tHcy, total homocysteine; SFA, serum folic acid; Hcy, homocysteine; NTD, neural tube defect; MTHFR, methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase; SNPs, single nucleotide polymorphisms; DHFR, dihydrofolate reductase; +, useful; ++, very useful; +++, extremely useful.