Table 3.
Summary of the Quality Assessment of Each Instrument According to the Criteria of Terwee and Associates (2007) (some of the references were cited more than once)
| Reference | Instrument | Content validity | Internal consistency | Construct validity | Agreement | Reliability | Responsiveness | Floor/ceiling effect | Interpretability | Setting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gresham et al. (1986) | QIF | (?) | (+) | (?) | Rehabilitation | |||||
| Marino et al. (1993) | QIF | (+) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Marino et al. (1995) | QIF | (+) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Marino and Goin (1999) | Short-form QIF | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Yavuz et al. (1998) | QIF | (+) | (?) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Ditunno et al. (2000) | WISCI I | (+) | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation | |||||
| Dittuno and Dittuno (2001) | WISCI II | (+ to −) | (?) | NR | ||||||
| Ditunno et al. (2007) | WISCI II | (+) | Rehabilitation & community | |||||||
| Ditunno et al. (2008) | WISCI II | (+) | (?) | (−) | Rehabilitation & community | |||||
| Kim et al. (2007) | WISCI II | (−) | (−) | Community | ||||||
| Morganti et al. (2005) | WISCI II | (+) | (−) | (−) | Community | |||||
| van Hedel et al. (2005) | WISCI II | (+) | (?) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| van Hedel et al. (2006) | WISCI II | (−) | (?) | Rehabilitation & community | ||||||
| Davidoff et al. (1990) | FIM | (−) | (−) | Acute care & rehabilitation | ||||||
| Roth et al. (1990) | FIM | Rehabilitation | ||||||||
| Grey and Kennedy (1993) | FIM | (−) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Marino et al. (1993) | FIM | Rehabilitation | ||||||||
| Segal et al. (1993) | FIM | (?) | (?) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Yavuz et al. (1998) | FIM | (+) | (?) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Dijkers and Yavuzer (1999) | Short-form motor FIM | (+) | Community | |||||||
| Hall et al. (1999) | FIM | (?) | (−) | (?) | Rehabilitation & community | |||||
| Kucukdeveci et al. (2001) | FIM | (+ to −) | (+) | (+ to −) | Rehabilitation | |||||
| Beninato et al. (2004) | FIM | (+) | (?) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Masedo et al. (2005) | FIM Self Report | (+) | (+) | (?) | (?) | Community | ||||
| Nilsson et al. (2005) | FIM | (+ to −) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Lawton et al. (2006) | FIM | (+ to −) | (−) | (−) | Rehabilitation | |||||
| Lundgren-Nilsson et al. (2006) | FIM | (−) | (−) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Catz et al. (1997) | SCIM I | (+) | (?) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Catz, Itzkovich, Agranov et al. (2001) | SCIM I | (+) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Catz, Itzkovich, Steinberg et al. (2001) | SCIM II | (+) | (+ to −) | (+) | Rehabilitation | |||||
| Catz et al. (2002) | SCIM II | (−) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Itzkovich et al. (2002) | SCIM II | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Itzkovich et al. (2003) | SCIM II | (+ to −) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Catz et al. (2007) | SCIM III | (+) | (−) | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation | ||||
| Itzkovich et al. (2007) | SCIM III | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| Roth et al. (1990) | Modified Bathel Index | (+) | Rehabilitation | |||||||
| Kucukdeveci et al. (2000) | Barthel Index (Turkish version) | (+) | (+ to −) | (+ to −) | Rehabilitation | |||||
| van Hedel et al. (2005) | TUG | (+) | (+ to −) | (+) | Rehabilitation & community | |||||
| van Hedel et al. (2008) | TUG | (+) | Rehabilitation & community | |||||||
| van Hedel et al. (2005) | 6MWT | (+) | (−) | (?) | (+) | Rehabilitation & community | ||||
| van Hedel et al. (2006) | 6MWT | (+) | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation & community | |||||
| Olmos et al. (2008) | 6MWT | (−) | (+) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| van Hedel et al. (2005) | 10MWT | (+) | (+ to −) | (?) | (+) | Rehabilitation & community | ||||
| van Hedel et al.(2006) | 10MWT | (+) | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation & community | |||||
| Olmos et al. (2008) | 10MWT | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation | ||||||
| van Hedel et al. (2008) | 10MWT | (+) | (+) | Rehabilitation & community |
+, positive rating; −, negative rating; ?, indeterminate rating due to lack of information or poor study design /method; NA, not applicable; NR, not reported.