Skip to main content
. 2010 Jan;52(Suppl1):S317–S340. doi: 10.4103/0019-5545.69261

Table 7.

Efficacy studies of antipsychotic in acute psychosis

Authors Duration (weeks) Sample size/scale/design Medication (s) Dose (s) mg Outcome Side effects
Mokashi and Chandorkar[78] 5 days N = 60; DBPCT, Consecutive sampling, Acute psychosis TPZ CPZ vs. PBO TPZ 15 CPZ 50
  • In the TPZ group, 17 subjects had relief of symptoms, 1 showed good improvement, 1 partial improvement and 1 no improvement

  • In the CPZ group, 8 subjects had relief of symptoms, 2 showed good improvement; 7 showed partial improvement and 3 no improvement

  • In the placebo group, 4 subjects had relief of symptoms, 1 showed good improvement, 2 partial improvement and 13 no improvement

  • TPZ was more effective than CPZ in overactivity, agitation and over talkativeness

  • Male subjects showed better response than female subjects

  • The hypokinetic hypertonic reaction was noted in 8 cases receiving TPZ and in 4 cases receiving CPZ group

  • All cases in both groups responded to phenargan

  • Hypotension was noted in one case under CPZ group

  • Placebo did not show any side reaction

  • In none of the cases the trial had to be abandoned due to toxic reaction

Fernandes et al.[74] 8 N = 46; ATP, BPRS Inj Zuclo phenthixol Zuclo penthixol acetate-50-250 Zuclo penthixol-200-600
  • Zuclopenthixol Acetate (acuphase) -category of severely ill reduced from 55% to 20.8% at 72 hours

  • Mildly ill category increased from 0.8% to 15% during the same period

  • CGI very much improved and much improved - 27% at 24 hours and 34% at 72 hours

  • Zuclopenthixol Decanoate (depot)-CGI “very much Improved- 10% of the cases at the baseline, in 24% at 4 weeks and in 35% at 8 weeks

  • BPRS scores also showed significant reduction from a mean total score of 58 at the baseline to 39 at 4 weeks and 36 at 8 weeks

  • Neurological S/E (tremors, rigidity, hypokinesia, dystonia, akathesia, hyperkinesia), depression, asthenia, increased salivation, sedation, hypotension, headache.

Chaudhuri et al.[60] 4 N = 35; ICD-10 ATP, SBRCT, BPRS, GAF Risp vs. HPL Risp-4 HPL-15
  • There was no significant difference in lowering of BPRS score in the two groups. Subjects in both the groups had significant reduction in BPRS at 4 weeks compared to baseline rating.

  • All patients in HPL group and 40% patients in Risp group required THF

  • More subjects in the Risp group required lorazepam (for sedation), propranolol (for akathisia) and parenteral diazepam as compared to HPL group

DBPCT - Double blind placebo controlled trial; TPZ - Thioproperazine; CPZ - Chlorpromazine; PBO - Placebo; ATP - Acute and transient psychotic disorder; CGI - clinical global impression scale; BPRS - Brief psychiatric rating scale; SBRCT - Single blind randomized controlled trial; GAF - Global assessment of functioning; Risp - Risperidone; HPL- Haloperidol; THF- Trihexyphenidyl