Skip to main content
. 2011 Aug 15;6(8):e23158. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0023158

Table 2. Model outputs: Average Cost effectiveness ratio (ACER) (total diagnostic and treatment cost per life-year gained) for each diagnostic procedure.

Diagnostic Specimen % of patients successfully treated ACER (5% prevalence) ACER (20% prevalence) ACER (50% prevalence)
CXR None 77.0% $1,077 $270 $109
DQ Oral wash 27.0% $175 $46 $20
Expectorated sputum 54.0% $85 $24 $11
Induced sputum 67.5% $261 $68 $29
Bronchoalveolar lavage 67.5% $2,288 $574 $232
GMS Oral wash 27.0% $315 $81 $34
Expectorated sputum 46.8% $184 $48 $21
Induced sputum 63.0% $343 $88 $37
Bronchoalveolar lavage 73.8% $2,146 $539 $217
TBO Oral wash 27.0% $72 $20 $10
Expectorated sputum 64.3% $29 $10 $6
Induced sputum 67.5% $220 $57 $25
Bronchoalveolar lavage 72.0% $2,107 $529 $213
CW Oral wash 27.0% $221 $58 $25
Expectorated sputum 29.7% $194 $51 $22
Induced sputum 51.3% $367 $94 $39
Bronchoalveolar lavage 70.2% $2,218 $557 $225
IFA Oral wash 27.0% $1,543 $388 $157
Expectorated sputum 45.0% $923 $233 $95
Induced sputum 72.9% $749 $190 $78
Bronchoalveolar lavage 90.0% $2,127 $534 $216
PCR Oral wash 63.9% $279 $72 $31
Expectorated sputum 76.5% $231 $60 $26
Induced sputum 84.6% $363 $93 $39
Bronchoalveolar lavage 90.0% $1,864 $468 $189
nPCR Oral wash 74.7% $279 $72 $31
Expectorated sputum 81.9% $253 $65 $28
Induced sputum 90.0% $375 $96 $40
Bronchoalveolar lavage 90.0% $1,901 $477 $193
rtPCR Oral wash 80.1% $353 $90 $38
Expectorated sputum 82.8% $339 $87 $36
Induced sputum 85.5% $483 $123 $51
Bronchoalveolar lavage 89.1% $2,005 $503 $203

CXR: Chest x-ray; DQ: Diff-Quick; GMS: Grocott's Methenamine Silver Stain; TBO: Toluidine Blue O; CW: Calcofluor white stain; IFA: Immunofluorescence; PCR: Polymerase chain reaction; nPCR: nested PCR; rtPCR: real-time (quantitative) PCR.