Table 3. Occurrence of claustrophobic events during different phases of the MR procedure.
Intention-to-treat analysis | Per-protocol analysis | |||||
Short-bore MR group | Open MR group | P Value | Short-bore MR group | Open MR group | P Value | |
n/total n (% [95% CI]) | n/total n (% [95% CI]) | |||||
First MR imaging | ||||||
Total* | 33/85 (39 [28 to 50]) | 23/87 (26 [18 to 37]) | 0.08 | 30/82 (37 [26 to 48]) | 23/87 (26 [18 to 37]) | 0.16 |
Entering the examination room | 11/33 (33 [18 to 51]) | 1/23 (4 [0 to 22]) | 0.01 | 11/30 (37 [20 to 56]) | 1/23 (4 [0 to 22]) | 0.007 |
During positioning on the scanner table† | 17/33 (52 [34 to 69]) | 20/23 (87 [66 to 97]) | 0.009 | 17/30 (57 [37 to 75]) | 20/23 (87 [66 to 97]) | 0.03 |
During MR imaging | 2/33 (6 [1 to 20]) | 2/23 (9 [1 to 28]) | 1 | 2/30 (7 [1 to 22]) | 2/23 (9 [1 to 28]) | 1 |
MR imaging after cross-referral | ||||||
Total* | 19/23 (83 [61 to 95]) | 21/30 (70 [51 to 85]) | 0.35 | 12/16 (75 [48 to 93]) | 18/27 (67 [46 to 84]) | 0.73 |
Entering the examination room | 7/19 (37 [16 to 62]) | 3/21 (14 [3 to 36]) | 0.15 | 7/12 (58 [28 to 85]) | 3/18 (17 [4 to 41]) | 0.045 |
During positioning on the scanner table† | 4/19 (21 [6 to 46]) | 15/21 (71 [48 to 89]) | 0.002 | 4/12 (33 [10 to 65]) | 15/18 (83 [59 to 96]) | 0.009 |
During MR imaging | 1/19 (5 [0 to 26]) | 0/21 (0 [0 to 16]) | 0.47 | 1/12 (8 [0 to 39]) | 0/18 (0 [0 to 19]) | 0.4 |
Values are numbers (%) and 95% confidence intervals (CI). Percentages may not total 100% because of rounding. P values were obtained using the chi-squared and Fisher's exact test. See Figure 1 for the flow of patients.
*Patients who did not attend their MR appointment due to claustrophobia were classified as having an event for the intention-to-treat analysis but were not otherwise categorized.
Including preparation of the patients on the MR table.