Table 1.
Studies reporting associations between mastery and future occurrence of cardiovascular events or mortality.
Study | Participants | Design | Mastery Construct |
Mastery Measure | CVD Outcome | Results/Findings | Effect Size (Cohen’s d /Hazard Ratio) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Helgeson, 2003 | 199 men and 99 women treated for CAD with percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty, ages 31-80 years |
Prospective, 4-year follow-up |
Personal Mastery |
Cognitive Adaptation Index (which included the Pearlin and Schooler Mastery Scale); global and heart disease-specific measures of self- esteem, optimism, and control were aggregated into a single index score. |
Occurrence of a subsequent cardiac event 4 years after initial assessment |
Higher scores on the Cognitive Adaptation Index (i.e., positive outlook of the future, higher sense of mastery, and general positive regard for self) were predictive of reduced likelihood of having a cardiac event 4 years after baseline assessment. The independent association between the mastery scale and occurrence of cardiac events was not reported. |
d = −.38 (for ever having been hospitalized for a cardiac reason during the 4-year follow up period) |
Helgeson & Fritz, 1999 | 303 men and women treated for CAD with percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty, ages 31-80 years |
Prospective, 6-month follow-up |
Personal Mastery |
Cognitive Adaptation Index (which included the Pearlin and Schooler Mastery Scale); global and heart disease-specific measures of self- esteem, optimism, and control were aggregated into a single index score. |
Future occurrence of a cardiac event 6 months after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty |
Higher scores on the cognitive adaptation index (i.e., positive outlook of the future, higher sense of mastery, and general positive regard for self) were predictive of reduced likelihood of having a cardiac event 6 months after baseline assessment. The independent association between the mastery scale and occurrence of cardiac events was not reported. |
d = −.42 |
Kutner et al., 1997 | 349 dialysis patients, ages 60-87 years |
Prospective, 7-year follow-up |
Personal Mastery |
Pearlin and Schooler Mastery Scale |
Long-time survival | Higher mastery was associated with long-term survival. |
d = −.07 |
Penninx et al, 1997 | 2,829 noninstitutionalized older adults, ages 55-85 years |
Prospective, 29-month follow-up on average |
Personal Mastery |
5 of the 7 items of the Pearlin and Schooler Mastery Scale |
Mortality | Greater mastery was associated with reduced mortality risk controlling for age, sex, chronic diseases, and other CVD risk factors. |
d = −.06 |
Penninx et al., 2000 | 1002 moderately- severely disabled community- dwelling women, ages ≥ 65 year old |
Prospective, 3-year follow-up |
Emotional Vitality (high sense of personal mastery, being happy, and low depression and anxiety symptoms |
“Emotional Vitality Scale” included 2 Pearlin and Schooler scale items: “I can do just about anything I really set my mind to” and “I often feel helpless in dealing with the problems of life” |
Mortality and progression of disability |
Emotionally vital women were less likely to die after 3-year follow-up. They were also less likely to develop a new disability. The independent associations between the mastery measure and these outcomes were not reported. |
d = −.71 |
Surtees et al., 2006 | 20,323 men and women recruited through general practice age-sex registers, ages 40- 74 years |
Prospective, up to 6-year follow-up |
Personal Mastery |
Pearlin and Schooler Mastery Scale |
Mortality from all causes, CVD, and cancer |
Higher mastery was associated with lower rates of all 3 types of mortality controlling for age, sex, and prevalent chronic physical disease. Lower mastery was more associated with CVD deaths than cancer deaths. |
d = −.06 |
Surtees et al., 2010 | 19,067 men and women with no history of heart disease or stroke at baseline in a population-based sample, ages 41-80 years |
Prospective, median 11.3 person-years of follow-up |
Personal Mastery |
Pearlin and Schooler Mastery Scale |
CVD mortality | Lower mastery was associated with an increased risk of CVD mortality. This association was stronger for those who had low CVD risk at baseline. |
Hazard Ratio = 1.11 95% CI=1.00-1.23 |
Note. CAD = coronary artery disease; CVD = cardiovascular disease