Table 4.
Item analysis of different questions in the pretest and posttest in genetics (n = 16)a
Pretest | Posttest | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
General concept | Item number | Bloom's taxonomy | Question | % of correct answers | Item number | Bloom's taxonomy | Question | % of correct answers |
Probability | 2 | Application | Two fertilization events are independent. What is the probability that a couple with two boys will have another boy? | 81.3 | 1 | Analysis | Using a mix with 60% adenine, 20% guanine, 10% cytosine, and 10% thymine to make an in vitro polymerization reaction, what is the probability of obtaining an adenine–cytosine–thymine triplet? | 75 |
6 | Application | A bag has seven red balls and two white balls. What is the probability that when drawing two balls, both of them are white? | 25 | 12 | Analysis | What is the probability that two carriers for the recessive sickle cell trait have two kids, both affected or both normal? | 25 | |
Graph interpretation | 3 | Analysis | Which type of graph is used to evaluate the relationship between two quantitative variables? | 62.5 | 2 | Analysis | Which graph would you use to evaluate the relationship between the height of the plant and the weight of the fruit? | 81.25 |
4 | Analysis | Which type of graph is used to evaluate the distribution of potato weights under certain conditions? | 31.3 | 8 | Evaluation | Given a graph with the frequencies of blood types A, B, AB, and O in two different populations, choose the sentence with an adequate interpretation of the data. | 50 | |
11 | Evaluation | Given two different graphs that plot the number of individuals with three different genotypes vs. weight, choose the sentence that better describes the data. | 18.8 | 9 | Evaluation | Given two different graphs that plot the number of individuals with three different genotypes vs. weight, choose the sentence that better describes the data. | 68.75 | |
Correlation coefficient | 12 | Evaluation | A table with three columns with data from cattle is shown: father weight (Z), mother weight (X), and progeny weight (Y). Interpret the r value. | 18.8 | 3 | Evaluation | Given data from height of the plant and weight of the fruit, r = 0.89, determine the association of the two traits. | 62.5 |
p Value | 5 | Evaluation | Given the average peak size in two populations of Geospiza fortis, and the p value, determine if the differences between the two populations is significant. | 56.3 | 7 | Evaluation | Given a graph with the frequencies of blood types A, B, AB, and O in two different populations, choose the sentence with an adequate interpretation of the p value and its statistical significance. | 37.5 |
4 | Creating | The chi-square analysis of a dihybrid cross determines that the differences between the observed and the expected frequencies in F2 are not significant. If the critical value is 0.5, find the associated p value. | 25 |
aThe alternative choices for each of the questions can be obtained by requesting a copy of the tests from the authors.