Skip to main content
. 2011 Jul 19;157(1):3–13. doi: 10.1104/pp.111.179531

Table I.

Comparison of select models and crops

Parameter Arabidopsis Barley Brachypodium Foxtail Millet M. sinensis Maize Rice S. viridis Sorghum Switchgrass Wheat
Height (cm) 15–20 50–120 15–20 120–200 150–300 120–300 100 10–250 50–250 200–300 50–100
Densitya (plants m−2) 2,000 80–120 1,000 50 3–4 4 36 1,000 50 6 50
Growth requirementsb (controlled conditions) Simple Intermediate Simple Intermediate Demanding Demanding Demanding Simple Demanding Demanding Intermediate
Efficiently crossed? Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Reproduction Selfing Selfing Selfing Selfing Outcrossing Outcrossing/self-compatible Selfing Selfing Selfing Outcrossing Selfing
Typical generation time (weeks) 8–12 10–20 8–12 11–13 12 8–15 12–24 6–8 13–18 26 10–20
Seeds per plant >1,000 150–200 100–1,000 >10,000 >1,000 200–1,000 >1,000 >5,000 >1,000 >1,000 50–150
Transformation Extremely easy Efficient, but labor intensive Highly efficient Reported, but not efficient Inefficient Efficient, but labor intensive Highly efficient Efficientc Inefficient Efficient, but slow Inefficient
Genome size (Mb) 119d 5,500 272d 515 5,000 2,300df 382d 515 700de 2,400 16,000
Assembled genome sequence Finished genome sequence Draft genome sequencing in progress High-quality draft (finishing under way) Draft genome No Draft genomef Finished genome sequence Draft genome sequencing in progress Draft genomed Sequencing in progress Sequencing in progress
T-DNA resources Extensive None 10,000 lines available, 40,000 more planned None None Transposon mutants are available Extensiveg None None None None
Cell wall type Type 1 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2 Type 2
Photosynthesis C3 C3 C3 C4 C4 C4 C3 C4 C4 C4 C3
a

High-density planting under laboratory conditions.

b

The difficulty of growing plants is dependent upon their size and the range of environmental conditions tolerated. Thus, small plants that tolerate varied conditions have simple growth requirements and large plants that need carefully controlled environmental conditions have demanding growth requirements.

c

Unpublished data (T. Brutnell).

d

Assembled genome size.

e

Approximately 20% of the genome was not assembled because of the repetitive nature.

f

Assembly consists of sequenced BACs many of which contain unordered genes because of the difficulty associated with assembling repetitive DNA.

g

While rice has extensive insertional mutant resources, the availability of the resources is constrained by quarantine restrictions and intellectual property concerns.

HHS Vulnerability Disclosure