Table 2.
Correction of NCI 1994 data and additional follow-up for leukemia and resulting attenuated exposure-response relationships.
NCI study | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1994 follow-up originala,b | 1994 follow-up revisedc | 2004 follow-upd | Marsh et al. (2004) re-analysise | ||||
Highest peak(ppm) | No. deaths | RR (95% CI) | No. deaths | RR (95% CI) | No. deaths | RR (95% CI) | SMR (95% CI) |
Unexposed | 4 | 0.78(0.25-2.43) | 4 | 0.52(0.17-1.57) | 7 | 0.59(0.25-1.36) | 0.38* (0.10-0.97) |
>0-1.9(base) | 16 | 1.00 (—) | 23 | 1.00 (—) | 41 | 1.00 (—) | 0.50* (0.28-0.81) |
2.0-3.9 | 20 | 2.04(1.0-4.01) | 20 | 1.36(0.73-2.51) | 27 | 0.98(0.60-1.62) | 1.04(0.63-1.60) |
>4.0 | 29 | 2.46(1.31-4.62) | 29 | 1.60(0.90-2.82) | 48 | 1.42(0.92-2.18) | 1.31(0.88-1.89) |
Used by IARC in 2004;
ptrend = .001 (all groups), ptrend = .004 (exp. only);
ptrend = .021 (all groups), ptrend = .094 (exp. only)
ptrend = .02 (all groups), ptrend = .12 (exp. only)
p < 0.05.