TABLE 1.
A. 21 gene segments adopted from arthropod study of (Regier, Shultz, et al.(2008)) | |||
PCR amplicon name | Gene name/function | Fragment length(bp) | Average number of substitutions per nt2 sitea |
36fin1_3 | Syntaxin | 471 | 0.39 |
44fin2_3 | Glucosamine phosphate isomerase | 528 | 0.85 |
3007fin1_2 | Glucose phosphosphate dehydrogenase | 621 | 1.22 |
8091fin1_2 | Glucose phosphate isomerase | 666 | 1.22 |
3006fin1_2 | Dynamin | 222 | 1.24 |
113fin1_2 | Glycogen synthase | 975 | 1.27 |
acc2_4 | Acetyl-coA carboxylase | 501 | 1.31 |
69fin2_3 | Clathrin coat assembly protein | 627 | 1.36 |
109fin1_2 | Gelsolin | 594 | 1.40 |
3070fin4_5 | Alanyl-tRNA synthetase | 705 | 1.43 |
262fin1_2 | Proteasome subunit | 501 | 1.48 |
268fin1_2 | AMP deaminase | 768 | 1.68 |
270fin2_3 | (Hypothetical protein) | 447 | 1.70 |
3017fin1_2 | Tetrahydrofolate synthase | 594 | 1.74 |
40fin2_3 | Phosphogluconate dehydrogenase | 750 | 1.77 |
8028fin1_2 | Nucleolar cysteine-rich protein | 324 | 1.81 |
42fin1_2 | Putative GTP-binding protein | 840 | 1.95 |
3059fin1_3 | Arginine methyltransferase | 732 | 2.23 |
197fin1_2 | Triosephosphate isomerase | 444 | 2.30 |
192fin1_2 | Glutamyl- & prolyl-tRNA synthetase | 402 | 2.78 |
265fin2_3 | Histidyl-tRNA synthetase | 447 | 3.86 |
B. Gene segments from (Regier et al.(2009)), with estimated substitution rates | |||
nt3b/noLR1 + nt2c | Gene name | Fragment length | “nt2 est.”d |
85.0 | CAD | 2928 | 1.60 |
18.4 | DDC | 1281 | 1.62 |
22.4 | Enolase | 1134 | 1.17 |
10.8 | Period | 888 | 6.00 |
42.4 | Wingless | 402 | 0.34 |
Notes: Provided are PCR amplicon names, gene names/functions and fragment lengths (excluding nucleotide characters of uncertain alignment) of the 21 additional gene regions sequenced for 41 taxa, ordered by evolutionary rate at nt2 on a phylogeny for 13 arthropod exemplars (Regier2008c).
Average number of nucleotide changes per second codon position site, estimated by ML on a constrained tree of 13 divergent arthropod species, from table 2 of (Regier, Shultz, et al.(2008)).
Average number of nucleotide changes per third codon position site, estimated by ML on a constrained tree of 32 species of Bombycoidea (Lepidoptera), from table 4 of (Regier, Cook, et al.(2008)).
Average number of nucleotide changes per site in a character set consisting of nt2 plus all nt1 sites at which no leucine or arginine occurs in any taxon, estimated by ML on a constrained tree of 32 species of Bombycoidea (Lepidoptera), from table 4 of (Regier, Cook, et al.(2008)). This is an estimate of the rate of nonsynonymous change. The ratio of rates at nt3 to rates in this character set is an estimate of the relative rate of synonymous to nonsynonymous substitution.
Approximation of nonsynonymous substitution rate, for comparison to the 21 additional gene fragments above. Gene 19 in table 2 of (Regier, Shultz, et al.(2008)), not included in the 21 additional genes of this study, is a 600 base pair piece of CAD. Estimates of nonsynonymous rates (noLR1 + nt2, above) for the five genes genes used by (Regier et al.(2009)) were first converted to proportions of the rate for CAD, then rescaled to reflect the ranking of CAD among the nt2 rates for the 21 additional gene fragments. The result is an approximate scale of comparison for rates of nonsynonymous substitution across all 26 genes, assuming that rates of substitution at nt2 and at nt1 sites undergoing only nonsynonymous substitutions are comparable.