Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2012 Feb 1.
Published in final edited form as: Bull Math Biol. 2011 Jun 17;74(2):300–326. doi: 10.1007/s11538-011-9668-y

Table 1.

Average relative error (ARE) in model fitting to cell counts simulated in Scenario 1.

Model Parameter range ARE(%) of time to division of gen. 0 ARE(%) of time to division of gen. ≥1 ARE(%) of time to death of gen. 0 ARE(%) of time to death of gen. ≥1
Branching Process (2.9) ±5% 7.73 4.26 0.56 21.9
±10% 9.06 5.58 0.69 27.6
±20% 7.76 6.93 0.67 39.7
±30% 7.66 7.71 0.59 49.8
±50% 7.52 18.2 1.03 84.6
overall 7.95 8.53 0.71 44.7

Branching Process (2.10) ±5% 8.20 18.6 24.4 131
±10% 7.75 23.0 24.6 101
±20% 9.42 34.9 24.1 195
±30% 12.1 30.3 23.4 194
±50% 22.7 64.1 21.3 206
overall 12.3 34.2 23.5 166

Cyton ±5% 6.24 26.4 29.0 59.2
±10% 8.59 26.2 25.5 64.9
±20% 12.9 29.7 19.9 79.8
±30% 19.5 27.6 19.0 80.0
±50% 24.2 42.2 27.1 103
overall 14.3 30.4 24.1 77.4

Simple ODE ±5% 527 406 1.92 × 1010 5.65 × 1011
±10% 556 427 1.00 × 1010 3.76 × 1011
±20% 629 485 2.44 × 1010 5.62 × 1011
±30% 694 474 2.07 × 1010 2.40 × 1011
±50% 899 640 5.27 × 1010 1.03 × 1012
overall 661 486 2.54 × 1010 9.86 × 1011

Smith-Martin ±5% 321 155 1.68 × 1016 4.82 × 1015
±10% 297 168 1.30 × 1016 1.38 × 1015
±20% 315 178 5.52 × 1016 1.04 × 1015
±30% 352 171 1.37 × 1016 2.25 × 1015
±50% 406 227 7.34 × 1016 7.22 × 1015
overall 338 180 3.44 × 1016 3.34 × 1015