Table 1.
Design | Patients included, MS type | Dosage and duration | Primary outcome | Results | Evidence | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kamen and Erdman, 1953 [23] | Case report | 1; RR | Intrathecal HC and intramuscular ACTH; no specific data available | Recovery | Patient recovered | IV |
| ||||||
Boines, 1961 and 1963 [24, 25] | Open-label, uncontrolled, retrospective, unblinded follow up of 12–52 weeks | 42; no specific data available | 40–100 mg intrathecal MPA every 2-3 weeks for a total of 6 injections, then “follow-up booster injections” | “recovery, particular of spasticity”; no specific outcome data available | “80% of patients improved/showed excellent or good results” | IV |
| ||||||
Van Buskirk et al., 1964 [26] | Open-label, uncontrolled, prospective, unblinded | 20; no specific data available | Weekly increasing doses intrathecal MPA (20–80 mg), then booster injection monthly (80–100 mg MPA); follow up 1 week-16–months | “clinical improvement” | “no effect on frequency of exacerbations, but improvement in spasticity in 14 patients” | IV |
| ||||||
Goldstein et al., 1970 [27] | Open-label, uncontrolled, retrospective, unblinded | 38; no specific data available | 40–80 mg intrathecal MPA/4–8 times within 1-2 weeks; follow up 2–8 years | “improvement” | “79% improvement” | IV |
| ||||||
Nelson et al., 1973 [28] | Open-label, uncontrolled, prospective, unblinded | 23; RR, SP | 40–120 mg intrathecal MPA/1–23 times within 2 months; follow up 1–84 months | EDSS CSF changes | EDSS: 4 patients (17%) improved; significant increase of CSF protein | IV |
| ||||||
Rohrbach et al., 1988 [29] | double-blind, randomized, prospective | 42, “mainly chronic progressive” | Intrathecal TCA: 80 mg/3-4 times within 14 days Oral TCA: 48 mg/d, tapering off |
“spinal score” | Intrathecal TCA: “better improvement in the spinal score” | II |
| ||||||
Heun et al., 1992 [18] | open-label, prospective, randomized, unblinded, follow up of 21 days | Intrathecal TCA: 25 Systemic MPA: 25 | TCA: 40 mg on days 1, 8, and 15 MPA: 100 mg for 5 days, tapering off |
EDSS AI SSEP | EDSS improved in both groups (P < .01); EDSS changes between both groups n.s.; AI n.s. |
III |
TCA: triamcinolone-acetonide acid; HC: hydrocortisone; ACTH: adrenocorticotropic hormone; MPA: methylprednisolone acetate; RR: relapsing-remitting MS; PP: primary chronic progressive MS; SP: secondary chronic progressive MS; MIX: mitoxantrone, EDSS: expanded disability status scale; WD: maximum walking distance; WT: maximum walking time; SSEP: somatosensory evoked potentials; AI: ambulation index; CSF: cerebrospinal fluid; n.s: non significant.