Table 6. Comparisons of the MM-bone model outcomes under the condition of PMM = 0.055/day with experimental observations.
Stage I/II | Stage III | |||
experiments | simulations | experiments | simulations | |
RANKL | 1.62-fold [70] | 1.75-fold | 2.65-fold [69];2.26-fold [70];13.5-fold [71];15.67-fold [72]; | 4.35-fold |
IL-6 | 2.6-fold/4.22-fold [75] | 3.55-fold | 9.79-fold [75] | 10-fold |
OPG | ↓ [69];↑ [88] 1 | ↓ | 0.71-fold [73];0.73-fold [38];0.82-fold [74];0.59-fold [69] | 0.69-fold |
OBa | ↑ [67], [68], [89] | ↑ | ↑ [67], [68], [89] | ↑ |
OCa | ↑ [67], [68], [89] | ↑ | ↑ [67], [68], [89] | ↑ |
Bone turnover | ↑ [67], [68], [89] | ↑ | ↑ [67], [68], [89] | ↑ |
Bone volume | ↓ [67] | ↓ | ↓ [67] | ↓ |
MM cells | 3-fold [67] | ↑ | Up to 6-fold [67] | 4.48-fold |
Note 1: Clinically, it is observed that serum OPG concentrations decrease at the early stage of MM disease [69], while it is recently suggested that serum OPG concentrations increase compared with healthy controls [88]. The exact reasons to cause the different observations are still not known. Possibly, OPG is produced by various skeletal and extra-skeletal tissues [90], leading to serum OPG concentrations do not reflect its availability in the bone microenvironment [88].
Note 2: All the ratios of experiments are obtained by comparing with healthy controls, whereas all the ratios of simulations are obtained by comparing with steady state of the normal bone model.