Skip to main content
. 2010 Aug 16;1:10.3402/nano.v1i0.5161. doi: 10.3402/nano.v1i0.5161

Table 1.

Comparison between the optical properties of traditional organic dyes and QDs for biological application

Properties Organic dyes QDs Advantages of QD
Excitation spectrum Narrow Broad Organic dyes can only be excited by light of a specific wavelength due to the narrow excitation spectrum vs QDs that may be excited by light of a range of wavelengths, allowing multicolour QDs to be excited by a single wavelength of light.
Emission spectra Broad and asymmetrical Narrow and symmetrical The broad emission spectra of conventional dyes may overlap and this limits the number of fluorescent probes that can be tagged to biomolecules for simultaneous imaging in a single experiment. QDs have narrow emission spectra that can be controlled by altering the size, composition and surface coatings of the dots. Hence, multiple QDs emitting different colours can be excited by a single wavelength of light, making them ideal for multiplexed imaging.
Photobleaching threshold Low High Organic dyes bleach within a few minutes on exposure to light whereas QDs are extremely photostable due to their inorganic core, which is resistant to metabolic degradation and can maintain high brightness even after undergoing repeated cycles of excitation and fluorescence for hours. Hence, they can be used for long-term monitoring and cell-tracking studies.
Decay lifetime Fast (<5 ns) Slow (30–100 ns) The fluorescence lifetime of QDs is considerably longer than typical organic dyes that decay within a few nanoseconds. This is valuable in overcoming the autofluorescence of background tissues, hence improving signal to noise ratio.
Quantum yield Low High QDs have higher quantum yields, a larger absorbance cross section and a larger saturation intensity than organic fluorophores in aqueous environments, making them much brighter probes for in vivo studies and continuous tracking experiments over extended periods of time.
Absorbance cross section Low High
Saturation intensity Low High