Skip to main content
. 2011 Jul 1;3(3):175–179. doi: 10.4161/derm.3.3.15065

Table 1.

Characteristics of models for determination of glucocorticoid induced skin atrophy (modified after ref. 51)

In vitro monolayer cell cultures In vitro full-thickness skin models In vivo models In patients
Pro
  • Species: human and non-human

  • Low time/labor/comound consumption

  • High throughput

  • Easy handling

  • Low costs

  • Species: human

  • Epidermal/skin thinning is measurable

  • Easy to moderate handling

  • Topical compound application

  • Testing of formulations

  • Interaction among different cell types

  • Rather reliable/predictive

  • Epidermal/skin thinning is measurable

  • Moderate handling

  • Potential systemic side-effects measuable

  • Topical compound application

  • Testing of formulations

  • Current gold standard (OFA hr/hr rat)

  • Interaction among different tissues

  • Speciec: human

  • Highly predictive

  • Epidermal/skin thinning is measurable

  • Topical compound application

  • Testing of formulations

  • Interaction among different tissues

Con
  • Cells are kept under non-physiological conditions

  • Limited prediction

  • Combination of different test systems may be needed

  • Epidermal/skin thinning is not present

  • Topical application of compounds not possible

  • Testing of formulations not possible

  • High-priced models

  • Moderate to high time/labor consumption

  • Moderate compound consumtion

  • Medium throughput at most

  • Moderate to high costs

  • Species: non-human

  • Moderate to high time/labor/compound consumtion

  • Medium throughput

  • Ethical aspects

  • High costs

  • High hurdles before testing is possible (e.g., toxicological characterization)

  • Ethical aspects (risk of irreversible effects)

  • Low throughput

  • High costs