Different methods of analysing a randomised controlled trial
Explanation | Benefits | Negatives | |
---|---|---|---|
As treated | Analyses by treatment received | Easy to calculate Tries to address patient oriented question |
Results in non-random omission bias |
Per protocol | Omits all participants who do not follow protocol | Easy to calculate Tries to address patient oriented question |
Results in non-random omission bias |
Intention to treat | Analyses by randomisation, ignores whether treatment received | Easy to assess Provides good estimate of the effect of recommending a treatment to study population |
Underestimates value of receiving the treatment |
Contamination adjusted intention to treat | Analyses by randomisation, adjusts for whether treatment received | Provides good estimate of an individual’s risks and benefits of receiving a treatment | Overestimates population level treatment benefits Somewhat more difficult calculation |