Skip to main content
. 2011 Dec 6;1(2):e000290. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2011-000290

Table 2.

Allocation of effect categories related to types of article and age groups and differentiated by source (NL and the UK newspaper articles combined)

Categories Positive Neutral Negative Positive-to-negative ratio p Value
NL newspapers 65 66 93 0.69 0.116
UK newspapers 192 169 204 0.94
Scientific journals 191 106 55 3.50 <0.001
NL and UK newspapers (mixed) 257 235 297 0.86
Type of article
 Scientific journals
  Case study 4 4 5 0.80 <0.001
  Research 144 49 17 8.47
  Opinion 39 49 33 1.18
  Policy 3 5 0 3.00
 Newspapers*
  Interview 69 30 16 4.31 <0.001
  News report 88 125 188 0.47
  Science journalism 38 30 52 0.73
  Opinion 60 43 29 2.07
  Policy 2 7 12 0.17
Age group
 Scientific journals
  Adults 70 12 7 10.0 <0.001
  Paediatric 48 39 21 2.29
  Both 33 29 18 1.83
  Unspecified 40 26 9 4.44
 Newspapers
  Adults 176 145 120 1.47 <0.001
  Paediatric 18 20 84 0.21
  Both 22 33 43 0.51
  Unspecified 41 37 50 0.82
*

Statistically significant differences in effect distributions related to types of article were also observed in the UK newspaper articles (p<0.001) and in NL newspaper articles (p=0.011).

NL, the Netherlands.