Skip to main content
. 2011 Dec 21;6(12):e27326. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0027326

Table 1. Assessment of study quality.

Study Diabetes Outcome Loss to follow-up Major confounders control Quality
ascertainment ascertainment <20%(PC) <5%(HC) HBV HCV Alcohol drinking score
Ikeda Y 1998 [69] MR or MU MR - Yes Yes Yes No
Fujino Y 2001 [68] SR DC Unknown - No No Yes 1
Tazawa J 2002 [25] MR or MU MR - Yes No Yes No 6
Poon RTP 2002 [67] MR or MU MR - Yes Yes No Yes 7
Huo TI 2003 [66] MR or MU MR - Yes Yes Yes No 7
Huo TI 2003 [65] MR or MU MR - No Yes No No 5
El-Serag HB 2004 [24] MR MR - Yes No No No 3
Huo TI 2004 [62] MR or MU MR - Yes Yes No No 6
Coughlin SS 2004 [63] MR or SR CR Unknown - No No Yes 1
Batty GD 2004 [64] SR CR Unknown - No No No 1
Jee SH 2005 [61] MR CR Unknown - No No Yes 2
Park SM 2006 [60] MR or SR CR - Yes No No Yes 2
Inoue M 2006 [23] SR MR Yes - No No Yes 3
Khan M 2006 [22] SR CR Unknown - No No Yes 1
Lai MS 2006 [21] MR MR Unknown - Yes Yes Yes 6
Torisu Y 2007 [20] MR MR - No No No Yes 3
Komura T 2007 [59] MR MR - Yes Yes Yes Yes 7
Ioannou GN 2007 [29] MR MR - Yes Yes Yes Yes 7
Kawamura Y 2008 [57] MR MR - No No No Yes 3
Di Costanzo GG 2008 [28] MU or SR MR - Yes No No Yes 5
Veldt BJ 2008 [27] MR or MU MR - Yes No No Yes 6
Oba S 2009 [58] SR CR Unknown - No No Yes 1
Ogunleye AA 2009 [19] DR CR Unknown - No No No 1
Wang CS 2009 [18] MR CR Yes - Yes Yes No 7
Lam EK 2010 [56] MR Unknown Unknown - No No No 1
Chodick G 2010 [17] MR or MU CR No - No No No 2
Hung CH 2010 [26] MR DC - Yes Yes No Yes 6
Huo TI 2010 [55] MR or MU MR - Yes Yes Yes No 7

Abbreviations: CR, cancer registry; DC, death certificate; DR, diabetes registry; HC, hospital-based cohort study; MR, medical record; MU, medication use; PC, population-based cohort study; SR, self-report.