Table 2.
Advantages and disadvantages of commonly used spinal cord injury models for translational studies in nonhuman primates
Contusion | Anatomically incomplete transection | Anatomically complete transection | |
---|---|---|---|
Advantages | Relevance to most human SCI(blunt traums) Reasonably reproducible injury Particularly suitable for the study of neuroprotective therapy |
Critical physiological functions are preserved Less animal handling is needed Defining mechanisms of recovery Permanent, but modest, impairments allow the investigation of therapy-mediated functional improvements |
Axonal regeneration can be demonstrated more definitively Recovery of voluntary movements from complete paralysis unequivocally demonstrates therapy-mediated effects |
Disadvantages | Ischemia, cavity formation and tissue sparing Major loss of function with severe contusion Significant focus on daily care of the animal Difficult to distinguish between spared and regenerated nerve fibers |
May be less relevant than contusion injury for human SCI Sprouting of spared fibers, as opposed to regeneration of cut axons, can be the main mechanism of recovery |
High impact on the general health of the animal Psychological trauma Labor-intensive and skilled daily care The major functional impairment for the animal must be carefully balanced with the potential benefits to be gained for humans |