TABLE 7.6.
Author (reference) | Design | n () | Indication | Regimen | Duration | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Respiratory tract infections | ||||||
End of treatment success* | ||||||
Niederman et al (186) (Abst) | Prospective, randomized, double-blind | 433 (362) | Community-acquired pneumonia | A: 200 mg iv every day followed by T 200 mg oral every day | 7 to 14 days | A/T: 160/178 (90%) |
Ceft: 1 g iv every day followed by cefpo 200 mg oral bid (erythro iv or oral could be added here if atypical pneumonia suspected – dose not specified) | 7 to 14 days | Ceft/cefpo: 160/184 (87%) P=0.35 (regimens are “statistically equivalent”) Day 30 of study success* A/T: 137/159 (86%) Ceft/cefpo: 139/169 (82%) P=0.25 (regimens are “statistically equivalent”) |
||||
End of treatment success* | ||||||
Sullivan et al (187) (Abst) | Prospective, randomized, double-blind | 359 (300) | Community-acquired pneumonia | T: 200 mg oral every day | 7 to 10 days | T: 138/144 (96%) |
Clarithro: 500 mg oral bid | 7 to 10 days | Clarithro: 147/156 (94%) Day 30 of study success* T: 89% Clarithro: 86% (no CI or P, but regimens are “statistically equivalent”) |
||||
End of treatment success† | ||||||
Mandell et al (188) (Abst) | Summary of six multicentre, double-blind, comparative clinical trials | 257 (NA) | Community-acquired pneumonia caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae | A: 200 mg iv every day (2 trials) | 7 to 14 days | A/T: 93% |
T: 200 mg oral every day (4 trials) | 7 to 10 days | |||||
C: ceft or erytho, cipro or ampi/amox, clarithro, cefaclor, amox+erythro (route not specified) | NA | C: 94% | ||||
Day 30 of study success† A/T: 91% C: 88% | ||||||
End to treatment success* | ||||||
Graham et al (189) (Abst) | Prospective, randomized, Double-blind | 267 (191) | Nosocomial pneumonia | A: 300 mg iv every day followed by T 200 mg oral every day | 10 to 14 days | A/T: 68/88 (77%) |
Cipro: iv bid followed by oral with or without clinda or metro (no dosage given) | 10 to 14 days | Cipro: 80/103 (78%) | ||||
Aztreonam or vancomycin could be added to either group for documented Psuedomonas aeruginosa or MRSA, respectively | Day 30 of study success‡ A/T: 69% Cipro: 68% (no CI or P, but the regimens are “statistically equivalent”) |
|||||
Genitourinary tract infections | ||||||
At 5- to 9-days post-treatment | ||||||
Hook et al (205) | Prospective, randomized, open, noncomparative, dose ranging study | 39 (31) | Uncomplicated gonorrhea | T: 50 mg oral single dose (n=9) T: 100 mg oral single dose (n=12) T: 200 mg oral single dose (n=10) |
Single dose | T: 100% cure for all three regimens (as defined by post-treatment culture results) |
5- to 9-day post-treatment success‡ | ||||||
Jones et al (206) | Prospective, randomized, double-blind | 625 (394 clinically evaluable) | Uncomplicated gonococcal urethritis or cervicitis | T: 100 mg oral single dose | Single dose | T: 174/182 (96%) |
Oflox: 400 mg oral single dose | Single dose | Oflox: 208/212 (98%) The regimens produced an “equivalent” clinical response (95% CI calculated, but not reported); P not reported |
n () Number of patients (number of patients with complete data at the end of treatment or at follow-up if there was no evaluation at the end of treatment). Where n appears under regimen or indication, it refers to the number of clinically evaluable patients who received the treatment or had the condition.
Success defined as cure (resolution of baseline signs and symptoms) or improvement (partial resolution and no further antibiotic therapy required).
Definition of success (clinical efficacy) was not provided;
Success defined as cure (complete resolution of signs and symptoms) or improvement (incomplete resolution). A Alatrofloxacin; Amox Amoxicillin; Ampi/amox Ampicillin/amoxicillin; C Comparators; Ceft Ceftriaxone; Cefpo Cefpodoxime; Cipro Ciprofloxacin; Clarithro Clarithromycin; Clinda Clindamycin; Duration Length of treatment Erythro Erythromycin; iv Intravenous; Metro Metronidazole; MRSA Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus; NA Information not available; Oflox Ofloxacin; T Trovafloxacin