Table 1. Studies included in the meta-analysis.
Study | Modality | Subjects | Supraliminal rectal inflation conditions |
---|---|---|---|
Berman et al. (2000)23 | PET | Study 1: 13 (7 F) IBS | 20, 45 and 60 mmHg |
Study 2: 17 (6 F) IBS | |||
Hobday et al (2001)27 | fMRI | 8 M Controls | average 11 p.s.i. |
Lotze et al (2001)30 | fMRI | 8 Controls (4 F) | average 173.6ml |
Naliboff et al (2001)13 | PET | 12 (2 F) IBS | 45 mmHg |
12 (2 F) Controls | |||
Bonaz et al (2002)25 | fMRI | 11 (10 F) IBS | individually determined maximum tolerable volume |
Verne et al (2003)36 | fMRI | 9 (6 F) IBS | 55 mmHg |
9 (6 F) Controls | |||
Naliboff et al (2003)32 | PET | 42 (23 F) IBS | 45 mmHg |
Andresen et al (2005)22 | fMRI | 8 (3 F) Controls | individually determined perception threshold +10 mmHg |
8 (5 F) IBS | |||
Kwan et al (2005)29 | fMRI | 11 (7 F) Controls | individually determined moderate pain |
9 (6 F) IBS | |||
Berman et al (2006)24 | fMRI | 13 (6 F) Controls | 25 and 45 mmHg |
Naliboff et al (2006)33 | PET | 12 (8 F) IBS | 45 and 60 mmHg |
Song et al (2006)35 | fMRI | 12 F IBS | pain detection +20% |
12 F Controls | |||
Price et al (2007)34 | fMRI | 9 IBS | individually determined moderate pain (rating of 40 out of 100) |
Berman et al (2008)7 | fMRI | 14 F IBS | 25 and 45 mmHg |
12 F Controls | |||
Ringel et al (2008)4 | fMRI | 10 F Controls | 15 and 50 mmHg |
10 F IBS | |||
Elsenbruch et al (2009)26 | fMRI | 15 F IBS | individually determined discomfort level |
12 F Controls | |||
Kanazawa et al (2010)28 | PET | 32 M Controls | 20 and 40 mmHg |
Moisset et al (2010)31 | fMRI | 11 F Controls | individually determined non-painful sensation and moderate pain |
M: Male; F: Female |