Table 3.
Comparison between three approaches to obtain a template set for rats.
Paper | N/strain | MRI intensity corrections | Individual MRI registration previous average template | Template space | Probabilistic tissue segmentations | P & W atlas edition | Atlas-template registration | Neuroimaging applications |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MR system main field | N | |||||||
Schweinhardt et al. (2003) | 5/in vivo SD | Histogram equalization (not described) | Affine, based on minimizing the sum of the weighted distances between 49 landmarks pairs in the individual and atlas space | Paxinos and Watson | – | Second (Paxinos and Watson, 1989) | – | SPM spatial normalization. Right and left forepaw BOLD fMRI localization on the primary forelimb area of the somatosensory cortex (S1FL), visually evaluated (tested) |
4.7 T | ||||||||
Schwarz et al. (2006) | 97/in vivo SD | Receiver coil correction and square root to reduce inter-variability and enhance tissue separation | PCA-based rigid to P & W atlas, matching brains and atlas outer surfaces | Arbitrary | Brain, brain parenchyma, and CSF | Fourth (Paxinos and Watson, 1998) | – | SPM spatial normalization. Pharmacological-induced perfusion MRI (phMRI) localization with volume of interest (VOI) evaluation of both localization and spatial extent (tested) |
4.7 T | 468 | |||||||
Current | 30/in vivo Wistar | Receiver coil correction, histogram equalization (1D linear registration) and, for segmentation, anisotropic filtering to enhance tissue separation | Highly non-linear, based on a multi-resolution, multi-grid scheme | Minimal deformation | Brain, gray matter, white matter, and CSF | Sixth and latest (Paxinos and Watson, 2007) | ATPS based on weighted landmarks | SPM spatial normalization, SPM tissue segmentation and atlasing in low resolution MRI. Right and left of both forepaw and hindpaw fMRI localization with quantitative ROI evaluation and volumetry (all tested). ROI–ROI DTI-based connectivity (future work) morphological connectivity (future work) |
7.0 T | 96 |
Sprague-Dawley; P and W, Paxinos and Watson; ATPS, approximate thin plate splines.