Table 4.
Report first author | Degree of neoplasia | Number of patients | Number of biopsies | Mandated surveillance biopsy protocol | Biopsy depth | Duration of follow-up | Percentage of patients found to have buried metaplasia |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Herrero et al. (35) | EC, HGD, LGD | 24 | 1,272 | Yes | NR | Median 29 months | 12.5% (at NSQ junction) |
van Vilsteren et al. (36) | HGD, EC | 22 | NR | Yes | NR | Median 24 months | 0% |
Fleischer et al. (37) | No dysplasia | 50 | 1,473 | Yes | 85% LP or deeper | 5 Years | 0% |
Lyday et al. (38) | No dysplasia, IND, LGD, HGD | 338 in < 1 year cohort 137 in > 1 year cohort |
NR | No | NR | Median 9 months Median 20 months | 0% in both cohorts |
Pouw et al. (39) | HGD or EC | 24 | 1,201 | Yes | NR | Median 22 months | 0% |
Eldaif et al. (40) | No dysplasia, LGD | 27 | NR | No | NR | 8 Weeks | 0% |
Pouw et al. (41) | HGD or EC | 16 | 385 | Yes | 37–51% LP or deeper | Median 26 months | 0% |
Shaheen et al. (18) | LGD, HGD | 84 | 9,517 | Yes | NR | 12 Months | 5.1% |
Sharma et al. (42) | LGD, HGD | 62 | > 2,500 | Yes | NR | Median 24 months | 0% |
Vassiliou et al. (43) | All grades including no dysplasia | 15 | NR | Yes | NR | Median 20.3 months | 0% |
Ganz et al. (44) | HGD | 142 | NR | No | NR | 12 Months | 0% |
Gondrie et al. (45) | HGD, IMC | 12 | 363 | Yes | NR | Median 14 months | 0% |
Gondrie et al. (46) | HGD, IMC | 11 | 473 | Yes | NR | Median 19 months | 0% |
Hernandez et al. (47) | No dysplasia, LGD, HGD | 10 | 247 | Yes | NR | 3–38 Months | 10% |
Pouw et al. (48) | HGD, EC | 44 | 1,475 | Yes | NR | Median 21 months | 2.7% |
Sharma et al. (49) | No dysplasia, LGD | 10 | 886 | Yes | NR | 2 Years | 0% |
Roorda et al. (50) | LGD, HGD | 13 | NR | Yes | NR | Mean 12 months | 0% |
Sharma et al. (51) | No dysplasia | 100 | 4,306 | Yes | NR | 12 Months | 0% |
EC, early cancer; HGD, high-grade dysplasia; IMC, intramucosal cancer; IND, indefinite for dysplasia; LGD, low-grade dysplasia; LP, lamina propria.
Note: A number of reports share the same authors, and we cannot exclude the possibility that some patients were included in more than one series.