Skip to main content
. 2011 Sep 20;470(2):339–350. doi: 10.1007/s11999-011-2058-9

Table 1.

Digestion protocols to isolate metal wear debris

Study Year Digestion Purification Display Image Total number of particles examined Measured parameters Statistics
Schmiedberg et al. [38] 1994 Papain, proteinase K (NaOH wash) Multiple sequential WCS (7 steps) Drop evaporation SEM 20 Length, width Mean, SD
Doorn et al. [16]* 1998 Papain, proteinase K Multiple sequential WCS (4 steps) Nebulization on TEM grid TEM 1–580 Diameter Box plots
Tipper et al. [41] 1999 KOH 60°C Extraction with chloroform:methanol (2:1) and repeated washes with 50% (v/v) acetone Filtration SEM 100 Mean dmax, aspect ratio (length/width), area, perimeter One-way ANOVA
Catelas et al. [10] 2001 Papain, proteinase K Multiple sequential WCS (6 steps) Resin embedding and slicing TEM 700–1300 Length, width One-way ANOVA
Brown et al. [4] 2007 Papain, proteinase K, yeast lytic enzyme, Zymolase® Multiple sequential WCS (12 steps) Sequential filtration SEM 150 dmax One-way ANOVA
Billi et al. 2011 Proteinase K, 37°C Density gradient centrifugation (1 step) Silicon wafer or TEM grid SEM or TEM Minimum 1000 dmin, dmax, P, A, ECD, FL, FB, FF, AR, E, R, shape and chemical composition distribution Nonparametric tests

* Particles isolated from tissue samples; WCS = washing/centrifugation/supernatant removal; TEM = transmission electron microscopy; SEM = scanning electron microscopy; dmin = minimum Feret’s diameter; dmax = maximum Feret’s diameter; P = perimeter; A = area; ECD = equivalent circle diameter; FL = fiber length; FB = fiber breadth; FF = form factor; AR = aspect ratio; E = elongation; R = roundness.