Table 1.
Study | Year | Digestion | Purification | Display | Image | Total number of particles examined | Measured parameters | Statistics |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Schmiedberg et al. [38] | 1994 | Papain, proteinase K (NaOH wash) | Multiple sequential WCS (7 steps) | Drop evaporation | SEM | 20 | Length, width | Mean, SD |
Doorn et al. [16]* | 1998 | Papain, proteinase K | Multiple sequential WCS (4 steps) | Nebulization on TEM grid | TEM | 1–580 | Diameter | Box plots |
Tipper et al. [41] | 1999 | KOH 60°C | Extraction with chloroform:methanol (2:1) and repeated washes with 50% (v/v) acetone | Filtration | SEM | 100 | Mean dmax, aspect ratio (length/width), area, perimeter | One-way ANOVA |
Catelas et al. [10] | 2001 | Papain, proteinase K | Multiple sequential WCS (6 steps) | Resin embedding and slicing | TEM | 700–1300 | Length, width | One-way ANOVA |
Brown et al. [4] | 2007 | Papain, proteinase K, yeast lytic enzyme, Zymolase® | Multiple sequential WCS (12 steps) | Sequential filtration | SEM | 150 | dmax | One-way ANOVA |
Billi et al. | 2011 | Proteinase K, 37°C | Density gradient centrifugation (1 step) | Silicon wafer or TEM grid | SEM or TEM | Minimum 1000 | dmin, dmax, P, A, ECD, FL, FB, FF, AR, E, R, shape and chemical composition distribution | Nonparametric tests |
* Particles isolated from tissue samples; WCS = washing/centrifugation/supernatant removal; TEM = transmission electron microscopy; SEM = scanning electron microscopy; dmin = minimum Feret’s diameter; dmax = maximum Feret’s diameter; P = perimeter; A = area; ECD = equivalent circle diameter; FL = fiber length; FB = fiber breadth; FF = form factor; AR = aspect ratio; E = elongation; R = roundness.