Skip to main content
. 2011 Dec 14;4:441–449. doi: 10.2147/JMDH.S26349

Table 2.

Indications, advantages, and disadvantages of surgical techniques for thyroid surgery

Surgical techniques Indications Advantages Disadvantages
Open thyroidectomy Any indication for thyroidectomy, lymph node dissection
Extrathyroid invasion
History of thyroiditis
Standardized method
Easy learning curve
Reduced operating time
Poor cosmetic result
Hyper- or paresthesia in the neck
Minimally invasive methods ≤30 mL of thyroid volume
<30 mm diameter of nodule
<20 mm diameter of cancer
Level IV node dissection
Better cosmetic result
Less postoperative pain
Difficult learning curve
Limits in nodules size
Breast and axillary-breast approaches <6 cm diameter of thyroid
<1 cm diameter of cancer
No central or lateral lymph nodes
Scarless technique Greater postoperative pain
Difficult learning curve
Longer operating time
Complications from CO2 insufflation
Higher cost
Robot-assisted thyroidectomy <6 cm diameter of thyroid
<2 cm diameter of cancer
No central or lateral lymph nodes
No previous neck operations
Better cosmetic result
Three-dimensional working field
Magnified view
Eliminate tremor
Highest cost
Greater postoperative pain
Longer operating time
Very difficult learning curve