Skip to main content
. 2011 Oct 12;195(1-2):26–40. doi: 10.1159/000331390

Table 2.

Comparison of cellular reagents for use in human experimental biology and clinical medicine

Cell source Advantages Disadvantages Application
Differentiated primary cells
  • Verifiable phenotype

  • Physiologically relevant

  • Well characterized

  • No/very low tumor risk

  • Limited supply

  • Can be difficult to harvest

  • Limited culture time

  • Graft-versus-host reactions (nonautologous)

  • Transplantation and grafting

  • Mechanistic studies in vitro


Adult multipotent progenitors
  • Relatively easy to harvest

  • Available in large quantities

  • No ethical issues

  • Relatively poorly defined mechanisms of action

  • Limited markers for analysis

  • Limited culture time

  • Limited plasticity

  • Cell therapy strategies

  • Mechanistic studies in vitro

  • Tissue engineering


Pluripotent stem cells
  • Plasticity to all three germ layers

  • Permits organogenesis strategies

  • Indefinite culture time

  • Good model for developmental biology

  • No ethical issues for iPS technology

  • Ethical issue associated with ES cells

  • Time-consuming approval processes

  • Risk of tumorigenesis

  • High cost to culture

  • Labor intensive to culture

  • Immature/embryonic phenotype

  • Cell therapy strategies

  • Tissue engineering

  • Organogenesis

  • Disease modeling in vitro

  • Developmental biology


Immortal cells
  • Available in large quantities

  • Indefinite culture time

  • Commercially available

  • Cost effective

  • High risk of tumorigenesis

  • Not useful in the clinical setting

  • Virus production

  • In vitro cancer research

The selection of cells for use in basic science or translational technologies is often an important decision. Considerations to be contemplated are whether the cells to be used in experimentation are relevant to the physiological equivalent, whether they are plentiful enough for the intended application, and whether they present special concerns like ethical issues.