Table 1.
Transgenic Mouse Model |
Phenotype | Limitations | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Early Models | Nf1Δ31/Δ31 | die by E13.5 due to cardiac failure |
early death prevents observation of tumorigenic effects of Nf1 loss |
|
Nf1Δ31/+ | develop pheochromocytomas (15% incidence); show accelerated development of other non-NF1 tumors as compared to wild-type mice |
no neurofibromas or MPNSTs observed |
||
Nf1−/−;Nf1+/− chimeras |
multiple plexiform neurofibromas present in animals with intermediate level of chimerism |
cannot control which cell types are Nf1+/− and which are Nf1−/− |
||
Nf1flox/flox;Krox20 -Cre |
Schwann cell hyperplasia | no neurofibromas or MPNSTs observed |
||
Nf1flox/−;Krox20 -Cre |
plexiform neurofibroma development by 1yr of age (demonstrating importance of both Nf1+/− and Nf1−/− cells in neurofibroma formation) |
Krox20 promoter is expressed in Schwann cells and boundary cap cells, making it hard to identify a clear progenitor |
||
Tumor Microenvironment Models |
Nf1flox/flox; Krox2- Cre transplanted with Nf1+/− bone marrow |
developed plexiform neurofibromas infiltrated by donor mast cells (demonstrating importance of Nf1 haploinsufficiency in hematopoeitic lineage for neurofibroma formation) |
Other Nf1+/− cell types within the hematopoietic lineage may contribute to neurofibroma development |
|
Nf1flox/flox; Krox2- Cre transplanted with Nf1+/−;c- KitW41/W41 bone marrow |
no neurofibromas developed (demonstrating importance of c-Kit signaling in Nf1 haploinsufficient cells in the hematopoeitic lineage) |
|||
Nf1flox/+; Krox2- Cre transplanted with Nf1+/+ bone marrow |
no neurofibromas developed (demonstrating importance of Nf1 haploinsufficiency in hematopoeitic lineage for neurofibroma formation) |
|||
Tumor Cell of Origin Models |
Nf1 ablation in Migrating Neural Crest |
Nf1flox/−; Wnt1- Cre, |
died at birth; no neurofibromas developed |
early death prevents observation of tumorigenic effects of Nf1 loss |
Nf1flox/-; Mpz-Cre | ||||
Nf1flox/−; Pax3- Cre | ||||
ablation in Schwann Cell |
Nf1flox/−; 3.9Periostin-Cre | died by 4 weeks after birth; no neurofibroma development observed |
early death prevents observation of tumorigenic effects of Nf1 loss |
|
Nf1flox/−; P0a-Cre | plexiform neurofibroma formation observed by 15-20 months |
due to broad P0a promoter expression in the Schwann cell lineage, a definitive cell of origin still could not be identified |
||
Nf1flox/flox; Dhh- Cre |
plexiform and subcutaneous neurofibroma development (demonstrating that an Nf1+/− microenvironment might not be strictly required for neurofibroma formation) |
Dhh promoter expression in progenitor cells capable of differentiation into both Schwann cells and endoneurial fibroblasts |
||
Nf1 ablation in SKPs |
Nf1flox/−; CMV- CreERT2; Rosa26 |
dermal neurofibromas generated ~6 months following topical tamoxifen administration |
likely that ablation of Nf1 in non-SKP cells in dermis contributes to neurofibroma formation |
|
MPNST Formation Driven by Dual Tumor Suppressor Loss |
trans-linked Nf1+/−;p53+/− |
developed non-MPNST sarcomas characteristic of p53 LOH |
no MPNST formation | |
cis-linked Nf1+/− ;p53+/− |
developed MPNSTs (~30% incidence) |
no neurofibroma precursor lesion | ||
Nf1+/−p16Ink4a−/− | accelerated development of tumors characteristic of p16INK4a loss |
no MPNST formation | ||
Nf1+/−p19Arf−/− | accelerated development of tumors characteristic of p19Arf loss |
no MPNST formation | ||
Nf1+/− p16Ink4a/p19Arf−/− |
developed MPNSTs (~30% incidence) |
no neurofibroma precursor lesion | ||
PNS Tumor Formation Driven by Ras Activation |
LSLNrasG12V/+; CAMK2-Cre |
pigmentary abnormalities of skin and dermal neurofibromas observed |
expression of the CAMK2 promoter in the Schwann cell lineage has not been clearly defined |
|
LSLKras2BG12D/+; mGFAP-Cre |
no obvious phenotype | no neurofibromas observed | ||
LSLKras2BG12D/+ Ptenflox/+; mGFAP-Cre |
plexiform neurofibroma development by 4 months of age with progression to MPNSTs by 7 months |
unclear how necessary Pten loss of function is to neurofibroma formation in the context of Nf1 loss |
||
PNS Tumor Formation Driven by Dysregulated Growth Factor Signaling |
P0-GGF β 3 | neurofibroma formation with progression to MPNSTs by 6- 10 months |
not yet clear whether and how dysregulated NRG1 signaling interacts with neurofibromin loss |
|
CNPase-EGFR | Schwann cell hyperplasia with mast cell recruitment and fibrosis |
neurofibroma formation exceedingly rare at very advanced age; no MPNSTs observed |