Table 1.
Study/Method | Subjects | Domains |
Singer et al (10) | Outpatients on dialysis or with human immunodeficiency virus | Receiving adequate pain and symptom management |
Qualitative: In-person, open-ended interviews | Residents of long term care facility | Avoiding inappropriate prolongation of dying |
Achieving a sense of control | ||
Relieving burden | ||
Strengthening relationships with loved ones | ||
Steinhauser et al (9) | Outpatients with cancer or human immunodeficiency virus | Pain and symptom management |
Qualitative: Focus groups and in-person interviews | Bereaved family members | Clear decision making |
Healthcare professionals and volunteers | Preparation for death | |
Completion | ||
Contributing to others | ||
Affirmation of the whole person | ||
Teno et al (8) | Bereaved family members | Provides physical comfort to patients |
Qualitative: Focus groups | Helps patients take control over decisions about medical care and daily routines | |
Relieves family burden of being present at all times to advocate for the patient | ||
Educates family to care for their loved ones at home | ||
Provides family with emotional support before and after the patient’s death | ||
Heyland et al (16) | Hospital in-patients with “serious illness” and their families (50% risk of death within 6 months) | Highest ratings among 28 items: |
Quantitative: Questionnaire-based interview | Trust and confidence in physicians | |
Avoidance of unwanted life support | ||
Communication with physician | ||
Life completion including life review, resolving conflicts, and saying goodbye | ||
Symptom relief | ||
National Consensus Project for Quality Palliative Care (6) | Professional consensus | Structure and processes of care |
Consortium of U.S. palliative care organizations | Physical aspects of care | |
Psychological and psychiatric aspects of care | ||
Social aspects of care | ||
Spiritual, religious, and existential aspects of care | ||
Cultural aspects of care | ||
Care of the imminently dying patient | ||
Ethical and legal aspects of care | ||
Critical Care Peer Workgroup - Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Promoting Excellence in End-of-Life Care Project (7) |
Professional consensus | Symptom management and comfort care |
Patient and family-centered decision making | ||
Communication within the team and with patients and families | ||
Emotional and practical support for patients and families | ||
Spiritual support for patients and families | ||
Continuity of care | ||
Emotional and organizational support for intensive care unit clinicians |