TABLE 1.
Rank Order of Frequency of DSM-IV Personality Disorder Criteria at Baseline and 2 Years and Reverse Rank Order of Frequency of Remission of Criteria at 2 Years in Patients With Personality Disordera
Diagnostic Group | Criteria Present at Baseline (Most to Least Frequent)
|
Criteria Present at 2 Years (Most to Least Frequent)
|
Criteria Remitted at 2 Years (Least to Most Frequent)
|
|||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Criterion | % | Criterion | % | Criterion | % | |
Schizotypal personality disorder patients (N=85) | Paranoid ideation | 84 | Paranoid ideation | 58 | Paranoid ideation | 20 |
Unusual experiences | 80 | Unusual experiences | 54 | Ideas of reference | 26 | |
Odd beliefs | 76 | Odd beliefs | 48 | Odd beliefs | 28 | |
Ideas of reference | 76 | Ideas of reference | 48 | No friends | 31 | |
Social anxiety | 72 | No friends | 38 | Unusual experiences | 32 | |
No friends | 58 | Odd thinkingb | 36 | Odd thinkingb | 38 | |
Odd thinkingb | 47 | Social anxiety | 32 | Social anxiety | 46 | |
Odd behaviorb | 39 | Odd behaviorb | 22 | Constricted affectb | 47 | |
Constricted affectb | 38 | Constricted affectb | 13 | Odd behaviorb | 52 | |
| ||||||
Borderline personality disorder patients (N=201) | Affective instability | 95 | Affective instability | 63 | Impulsivity | 21 |
Anger | 87 | Anger | 57 | Anger | 22 | |
Impulsivity | 81 | Impulsivity | 55 | Affective instability | 23 | |
Unstable relations | 79 | Unstable relations | 53 | Unstable relations | 29 | |
Emptiness | 71 | Emptiness | 45 | Stress/paranoia | 35 | |
Stress/paranoia | 68 | Stress/paranoia | 44 | Emptiness | 39 | |
Identity disturbance | 61 | Identity disturbance | 35 | Identity disturbance | 40 | |
Abandonment fears | 60 | Abandonment fears | 31 | Abandonment fears | 46 | |
Self-injury | 60 | Self-injury | 30 | Self-injury | 46 | |
| ||||||
Avoidant personality disorder patients (N=266) | Feels inadequate | 93 | Socially inept | 62 | Socially inept | 19 |
Socially inept | 90 | Feels inadequate | 62 | Feels inadequate | 24 | |
Preoccupation with rejection | 88 | Preoccupation with rejection | 53 | Need to be liked before making social contacts | 28 | |
Need to be liked before making social contacts | 82 | Need to be liked before making social contacts | 51 | Fears ridicule, shame | 34 | |
Avoids interpersonal jobs | 67 | No risks, fears embarrassment | 44 | No risks, fears embarrassment | 34 | |
No risks, fears embarrassment | 64 | Fears ridicule, shame | 38 | Preoccupation with rejection | 35 | |
Fears ridicule, shame | 62 | Avoids interpersonal jobs | 31 | Avoids interpersonal jobs | 54 | |
| ||||||
Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder patients (N=221) | Problems with delegating | 83 | Rigidity | 52 | Rigidity | 24 |
Rigidity | 79 | Problems with delegating | 51 | Pack rat | 27 | |
Perfectionism | 79 | Perfectionism | 44 | Problems with delegating | 30 | |
Pack rat | 63 | Pack rat | 41 | Perfectionism | 34 | |
Concern with rules, details, lists | 61 | Concern with rules, details, lists | 32 | Workaholic | 35 | |
Inflexible about morality | 58 | Workaholic | 29 | Concern with rules, details, lists | 39 | |
Workaholic | 49 | Inflexible about morality | 27 | Inflexible about morality | 41 | |
Miserly | 31 | Miserly | 10 | Miserly | 49 |
Participants were ages 18–45 years and were recruited from among patients seeking treatment at clinical services affiliated with the sites of the Collaborative Longitudinal Personality Disorders Study.
Observational criterion.