Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2012 Feb 6.
Published in final edited form as: Am J Psychiatry. 2005 May;162(5):883–889. doi: 10.1176/appi.ajp.162.5.883

TABLE 1.

Rank Order of Frequency of DSM-IV Personality Disorder Criteria at Baseline and 2 Years and Reverse Rank Order of Frequency of Remission of Criteria at 2 Years in Patients With Personality Disordera

Diagnostic Group Criteria Present at Baseline (Most to Least Frequent)
Criteria Present at 2 Years (Most to Least Frequent)
Criteria Remitted at 2 Years (Least to Most Frequent)
Criterion % Criterion % Criterion %
Schizotypal personality disorder patients (N=85) Paranoid ideation 84 Paranoid ideation 58 Paranoid ideation 20
Unusual experiences 80 Unusual experiences 54 Ideas of reference 26
Odd beliefs 76 Odd beliefs 48 Odd beliefs 28
Ideas of reference 76 Ideas of reference 48 No friends 31
Social anxiety 72 No friends 38 Unusual experiences 32
No friends 58 Odd thinkingb 36 Odd thinkingb 38
Odd thinkingb 47 Social anxiety 32 Social anxiety 46
Odd behaviorb 39 Odd behaviorb 22 Constricted affectb 47
Constricted affectb 38 Constricted affectb 13 Odd behaviorb 52

Borderline personality disorder patients (N=201) Affective instability 95 Affective instability 63 Impulsivity 21
Anger 87 Anger 57 Anger 22
Impulsivity 81 Impulsivity 55 Affective instability 23
Unstable relations 79 Unstable relations 53 Unstable relations 29
Emptiness 71 Emptiness 45 Stress/paranoia 35
Stress/paranoia 68 Stress/paranoia 44 Emptiness 39
Identity disturbance 61 Identity disturbance 35 Identity disturbance 40
Abandonment fears 60 Abandonment fears 31 Abandonment fears 46
Self-injury 60 Self-injury 30 Self-injury 46

Avoidant personality disorder patients (N=266) Feels inadequate 93 Socially inept 62 Socially inept 19
Socially inept 90 Feels inadequate 62 Feels inadequate 24
Preoccupation with rejection 88 Preoccupation with rejection 53 Need to be liked before making social contacts 28
Need to be liked before making social contacts 82 Need to be liked before making social contacts 51 Fears ridicule, shame 34
Avoids interpersonal jobs 67 No risks, fears embarrassment 44 No risks, fears embarrassment 34
No risks, fears embarrassment 64 Fears ridicule, shame 38 Preoccupation with rejection 35
Fears ridicule, shame 62 Avoids interpersonal jobs 31 Avoids interpersonal jobs 54

Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder patients (N=221) Problems with delegating 83 Rigidity 52 Rigidity 24
Rigidity 79 Problems with delegating 51 Pack rat 27
Perfectionism 79 Perfectionism 44 Problems with delegating 30
Pack rat 63 Pack rat 41 Perfectionism 34
Concern with rules, details, lists 61 Concern with rules, details, lists 32 Workaholic 35
Inflexible about morality 58 Workaholic 29 Concern with rules, details, lists 39
Workaholic 49 Inflexible about morality 27 Inflexible about morality 41
Miserly 31 Miserly 10 Miserly 49
a

Participants were ages 18–45 years and were recruited from among patients seeking treatment at clinical services affiliated with the sites of the Collaborative Longitudinal Personality Disorders Study.

b

Observational criterion.