Ref (type) | Population | Outcome, Interventions | Results and statistical analysis | Effect size | Favours |
Re-intervention / restenosis | |||||
RCT |
279 people with intermittent claudication and iliac artery stenosis |
Proportion of people requiring reintervention
10/143 (7%) with percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) plus routine stenting 6/136 (4%) with PTA plus selective stenting |
ARR +3% 95% CI –3% to +8% |
Not significant | |
RCT |
73 people with severe intermittent claudication, chronic critical limb ischaemia or ischaemic ulcers, and superficial femoral artery stenosis or occlusion |
Proportion of people with >50% restenosis according to duplex ultrasound
3 months
1/34 (3%) with PTA plus routine stenting (nitinol self-expanding stents) 7/37 (19%) with PTA with optional secondary stenting |
P = 0.033 |
Effect size not calculated | PTA plus routine stenting |
RCT |
73 people with severe intermittent claudication, chronic critical limb ischaemia or ischaemic ulcers, and superficial femoral artery stenosis or occlusion |
Proportion of people with >50% restenosis
6 months
7/32 (22%) with PTA plus routine stenting (nitinol self-expanding stents) 20/36 (56%) with PTA with optional secondary stenting |
Intention-to-treat analysis P = 0.005 |
Effect size not calculated | PTA plus routine stenting |
RCT |
227 people with severe claudication or limb-threatening stenosis of the superficial femoral artery |
Proportion of people who died or had >50% restenosis
1 year
30/89 (34%) with PTA plus routine stenting 29/86 (33%) with PTA plus selective stenting |
P = 0.9 |
Not significant | |
RCT |
104 people with severe claudication caused by stenosis or occlusion of the superficial femoral artery Further report of reference |
Proportion of people with restenosis
12 months
18/49 (37%) with PTA plus routine stenting (primary nitinol self-expanding stents) 33/52 (63%) with balloon angioplasty with optional secondary stenting |
P = 0.01 |
Effect size not calculated | PTA plus routine stenting |
RCT |
73 people with severe intermittent claudication, chronic critical limb ischaemia or ischaemic ulcers, and superficial femoral artery stenosis or occlusion |
Proportion of people with >50% restenosis according to duplex ultrasound
12 months
11/32 (34%) with PTA plus routine stenting (nitinol self-expanding stents) 22/36 (61%) with PTA with optional secondary stenting |
Intention-to-treat analysis P = 0.028 |
Effect size not calculated | PTA plus routine stenting |