Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: Neuroimage. 2011 Dec 21;60(1):252–262. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.12.024

Table 2.

Data source, sample size (n), and number of activation foci for all studies included in the meta-analysis.

Study Stimulus Type Stimulus Duration (s) Data Source n Foci
Non-deprived Smokers
McBride et al. (2006) Videos 120 Table 3 19 5
David et al. (2007)a Pictures 5 Table 1 8 2
Brody et al. (2007) Videos 45 Table 1 42 17
McClernon et al. (2008) Pictures 4 Table S6 30 18
Janes et al. (2009) Pictures 4 Table 1 13 25
Rubinstein et al. (2011) Pictures 18b Table 2 12 4
Franklin et al. (2011a) Videos 600 Table 3 26 1
Hartwell et al. (2011) Pictures 24c Table 1 31 12
Total 181 84
Deprived Smokers
David et al. (2005) Pictures 5 Table 1 9 3
Lee et al. (2005) Pictures 30 Table 2 8 11
David et al. (2007)a Pictures 5 Table 1 8 2
McClernon et al. (2009) Pictures 60d Table 1 18 19
Total 43 35
Totals for pooled analysis 224 119
a

This study used a within-subjects design, in which the same participants were scanned when non-deprived and when deprived of cigarettes for 12 h. For purposes of the pooled meta-analysis, these two conditions were modeled as independent studies. Thus, the effective sample size for the pooled analysis was 224, even though there were only 216 individual smokers enrolled across all studies.

b

This study used a blocked design, in which the 18 s stimulation period consisted of consecutive presentation of 3 pictures from the same category for 6 s each. In the study, the data were modeled as a single, 18 s stimulus.

c

This study used a blocked design, in which the 24 s stimulation period consisted of consecutive presentation of 5 pictures from the same category for 4.8 s each. In the study, the data were modeled as a single, 24 s stimulus.

d

This study used a blocked design, in which the 60 s stimulation period consisted of consecutive presentation of 10 pictures from the same category for 6 s each. In the study, the data were modeled as a single, 60 s stimulus.