Table 1.
Modality author [Ref] | Intervention | Number of patients |
Overall survival (5 years) | Median survivals (months) | Progression/disease-free survival | Clinical response | Biochemical response | Radiological response |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Liver surgery | ||||||||
| ||||||||
Sarmiento et al. [3] | Resection | 170 | 61% | |||||
Touzios et al. [4] | Resection ± ablation | 18 | 72% | >96 | ||||
Grazi et al. [5] | Resection | 19 | 92% (4 yrs) | |||||
Kianmanesh et al. [6] | Resection | 23 | 94% | 50% (5 yrs) | ||||
Gomez et al. [7] | Resection | 18 | 86% | 66% (5 yrs) | ||||
Scigliano et al. [8] | Resection | 41 | 79% | 3% (5 yrs) | ||||
Osborne et al. [9] | Cytoreduction | 61 | Curative-50 (mean) | |||||
Palliative-32 (mean) | ||||||||
Musunuru et al. [10] | Resection ± ablation | 13 | 83% (3 yrs) | |||||
Mayo et al. [11] | Resection ± ablation | 339 | 74% | 125 | ||||
| ||||||||
Liver transplantation | ||||||||
| ||||||||
Lehnert [12] | 103 | 47% | ||||||
Olausson et al. [13] | 15 | 90% | 20% (5 years) | |||||
Le Treut et al. [14] | 85 | 47% | ||||||
| ||||||||
Embolisation | ||||||||
| ||||||||
Ho et al. [15] | TAE or TACE | 46 | 42 | 18 months | ||||
Ruutiainen et al. [16] | TACE | 57 | 50% | 35% (3 yrs) | ||||
Strosberg et al. [17] | TAE | 84 | 36 | |||||
Dong and Carr [18] | TACE | 123 | 36% | 39 (mean) | ||||
Ruszniewski et al. [19] | TACE | 24 | 73% | 57% | 33% | |||
Gupta et al. [20] | TAE or TACE | 69 (Carcinoid) | 22 months | 67% | ||||
54 (Pancreatic) | 16 months | 35% | ||||||
| ||||||||
RFA | ||||||||
| ||||||||
Mazzaglia et al. [21] | 63 | 46 (after RFA) | 70% | |||||
| ||||||||
SIRT | ||||||||
| ||||||||
King et al. [22] | 37 | 29 (mean) | 55% | 43% | 50% | |||
Kennedy et al. [23] | 148 | 70 | 63% | |||||
Cao et al. [24] | 58 | 47% (3 yrs) | 36 | 34% | ||||
Saxena et al. [25] | 48 | 35 | 55% |