TABLE 4.
Elements of a teaching plan in pain and the humanities (four sessions of 2 h each)
Philosophy | Fine arts | Literature | Drama |
---|---|---|---|
Team-based learning about philosophy dividing students into four philosophic schools: Aristotelian, Stoic, Epicurean and Utilitarian | Student presentations of selected artworks: Kahlo, Bosch, Caravaggio, Dix and others. Leads to close observation | Poetry: Kahlil Gibran’s ‘On Pain’, and a discussion of the self-imposed nature of pain (or not), and differences due to culture | Movie excerpt: First 11 min of ‘Glory’ starring Broderick as a lightly wounded soldier observing unanesthetized leg amputation |
Students work to answer detailed questions on how their philosophic school conceives of pain and then solve a challenge question of clinical management from their school’s perspective | Guided observations and reflections on the evidence of pain exhibited in selected fine art works. Discussion of neurobiology controlling pain behaviour and what makes pain ‘believable’ | Prose: Contrast Stephen King’s pain narrative ‘On Impact’ to that of Doris Lessing’s childbirth narrative in ‘A Proper Marriage’ | Dramatic reading of John Milton’s ‘Samson agonists’. Samson is a man with many kinds of emotional degradation but little physical pain: important contrasts to physical pain here |
Lecture presentation of philosophic perspectives holds the promise of great breadth but is not interesting to all students | Crucifixion scenes offer a longitudinal and multicultural series of pain images but are heavily laden with potent cultural messages | Poetry alternative: Haiku of Basho and Issa has imagery of winter, dry bones, snails crying in the frying pan, a worm eating a chestnut | Role play where students adopt the roles of patients with specific pain-illness or the role of interns; prompts awareness of pain in diagnosis |