Skip to main content
. 2012 Feb 7;106(5):826–838. doi: 10.1038/bjc.2012.4

Table 2. QoL therapy procedures showing the best possible effectiveness for the five therapeutic options to cure diseased QoL in the context of the care pathway.

Procedure 1. Physiotherapy 2. Psychotherapy 3. Social support 4. Pain therapy 5. Nutrition and fitness
Definition of therapeutic option and methodsa Physical decongestive therapy of upper limb by manual lymph drainage with sequential compression therapy Individual, experiential psychotherapy and cognitive behavioural interventions for adjustment disorders Network nodes for social counselling (financial security, well-being, partnership, children, homecare, profession) organised in quality circle Combination of drugs (WHO analgesic ladder) with non-drug measures, for example, psychotherapy and disease-modifying therapies Combination of self-help groups: counselling for diet and ambulatory sports training programmes, all enrolled in quality circles
Level of evidence for an effective outcome measureb 1 Questionable effective (Preston et al, 2009) 1 Effective for QoL (Newell et al, 2002) 4 GCP Effectiveness not tested 1 Effective for pain (Hanks et al, 2001) 4 GCP Effectiveness not tested (Beliveau and Gingras, 2005)
Methodological standard achieved in local consensus of recommendationsc Formal consensus, Nominal Group Process (Lorenz et al, 2001) Informal consensus, decisions, cases analysed in quality circle Informal consensus within quality circle Informal consensus, locally tailored guidelines, in quality circle Informal consensus, developed only within QoL unit

Abbreviations: GCP=good clinical practice; QoL=quality of life.

General sources of information (Lorenz et al, 2001).

a

German national guideline for breast cancer (http://www.AWMF.de) in 2009.

b

Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) grading system in 1999.

c

German guideline manual in 2001 (Lorenz et al, 2001).