Skip to main content
. 2012 Feb;15(2):228–235. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2011.0207

Table 1.

Studies Included in Systematic Review

Reference Study design Study follow-up Level of evidencea
Carson et al., 200921 Prospective cohort study of patients with GFR<30 and age ≥70 receiving either CM or dialysis 95.0% 1
Chanda et al., 201017 Retrospective cohort study of patients with GFR<15 receiving either CM or dialysis n/a 2
Ellam et al., 200919 Retrospective cohort study of patients with GFR<15 receiving CM n/a 2
Joly et al., 200320 Prospective cohort study of patients with CrCl<10 and age ≥80 receiving either CM or dialysis 100% 1
Murtagh et al., 200718 Retrospective cohort study of patients with GFR<15 and age >75 receiving either CM or dialysis n/a 2
Smith et al., 200315 Prospective cohort study of patients with GFR<15 recommended for CM by multidisciplinary team 100% 1
Wong et al., 200716 Prospective cohort study of patients with GFR<30 receiving CM 100% 1
DeBiase et al., 200829 Observational study of patients with age >75 and GFR<15 recommended for CM n/a 2
Murphy et al., 200925 Cross-sectional survey of patients with GFR<30 receiving CM n/a 2
Murtagh et al., 200722 Cross-sectional survey of patients with GFR<15 receiving CM n/a 2
Murtagh et al., 201023 Longitudinal survey of patients with GFR<15 receiving CM, data presented from the month prior to death n/a 2
Saini et al., 200624 Cross-sectional survey of patients with GFR<15 receiving CM; survey also administered to comparison group of patients with terminal malignancy n/a 2
Yong et al., 200928 Cross-sectional survey of patients with GFR<15 receiving either CM or dialysis n/a 2

GFR, glomerular filtration rate; CM, conservative management; CrCl, creatinine clearance; n/a, not applicable.

a

Based on Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy (SORT) criteria: level of evidence 1=good-quality, patient-oriented evidence; level of evidence 2=limited-quality, patient-oriented evidence; level of evidence 3=other evidence.