Skip to main content
. 2012 Apr 19;344:e2292. doi: 10.1136/bmj.e2292

Table 5.

 Incremental cost effectiveness ratios and net benefit statistics for maternal morbidity avoided in women at low risk of complications according to planned place of birth: home, freestanding midwifery unit (FMU), or alongside midwifery unit (AMU) with obstetric unit (OU) as reference

Home FMU AMU
All low risk women
Cost difference (95% CI) −590 (−618 to −563) −247 (−280 to −211) −154 (−190 to −118)
Difference in maternal morbidity* avoided (95% CI) 0.195 (0.187 to 0.204) 0.172 (0.168 to 0.182) 0.116 (0.106 to 0.126)
Mean ICER (95% CI) −3024 (−3138 to −2912) −1442 (−1600 to −1284) −1322 (−1572 to −1049)
Quadrant on cost effectiveness plane South east South east South east
Mean net benefit (95% CI)† 4498 (4306 to 4669) 3683 (3451 to 3904) 2486 (2259 to 2692)
Mean net benefit (95% CI)§ 6451 (6175 to 6705) 5403 (5068 to 5716) 3651 (3322 to 3950)
Low risk women without complicating conditions
Cost difference (95% CI) −504 (−535 to −474) −150 (−186 to −115) −69 (−105 to −36)
Difference in maternal morbidity* avoided (95% CI) 0.165 (0.156 to 0.174) 0.139 (0.131 to 0.149) 0.088 (0.078 to 0.098)
Mean ICER (95% CI) −3052 (−3215 to −2902) −1075 (−1285 to −843) −782 (−1130 to −431)
Quadrant on cost effectiveness plane South east South east South east
Mean net benefit (95% CI)† 3808 (3620 to 4012) 2942 (2743 to 3166) 1828 (1605 to 2059)
Mean net benefit (95% CI)§ 5459 (5181 to 5754) 4340 (4051 to 4658) 2706 (2382 to 3040)

*Defined as at least one of: general anaesthetic; instrumental birth; caesarean section; third or fourth degree perineal trauma; blood transfusion; admission to intensive treatment unit, high dependency unit, or specialist unit; and maternal death (within 42 days of giving birth). This is composite measure and was also secondary outcome of interest in cohort study.

†Estimated at £20 000 cost effectiveness threshold.

§Estimated at £30 000 cost effectiveness threshold.