Table 4.
Credibility | Relevance | Perceived impact | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bivariate B (SE) |
Adjusted B* (SE) |
Bivariate B (SE) |
Adjusted B* (SE) |
Bivariate B (SE) |
Adjusted B* (SE) |
||
Age (continuous) | 0.02[0.01]c | 0.04[0.01]c | 0.06[0.01]c | 0.07[0.01]c | 0.02[0.01]c | 0.04[0.01]c | |
Sex | Female | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref |
Male | −0.05[0.11] | −0.05[0.11] | 0.23[0.17] | 0.12[0.17] | 0.14[0.12] | 0.15[0.12] | |
Education | |||||||
Secondary or less | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | ref | |
Technical school | −0.41[0.20]a | −0.45[0.20]a | −0.47[0.30] | −0.53[0.30]a | −0.25[0.21] | −0.3[0.21] | |
High school | −0.49[0.14]b | −0.39[0.14]b | −0.53[0.21]a | −0.34[0.21] | −0.50[0.15]b | −0.40[0.15]b | |
University or more | −0.54[0.16]b | −0.58[0.17]c | 0.03[0.24] | −0.12[0.24] | −0.42[0.17]a | −0.47[0.17]b | |
Smoking behavior | |||||||
Nonsmoker | −0.03[0.15] | 0.14[0.15] | 0.02[0.22] | 0.43[0.22]a | −0.04[0.15] | 0.15[0.16] | |
Nondaily smoker | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | |
Daily smoker, < 5 per day | −0.36[0.16]a | −0.46[0.16]b | 0.19[0.24] | 0.03[0.24] | −0.40[0.17]a | −0.50[0.17]b | |
Daily smoker, 5 or more per day | −0.34[0.15]a | −0.52[0.15]b | 0.71[0.23]b | 0.37[0.23] | −0.38[0.16]a | −0.58[0.16]b | |
Warning topic | |||||||
Throat cancer | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | |
Stroke | 0.05[0.12] | 0.05[0.12] | 0.01[0.18] | −0.01[0.17] | 0.22 [0.12] | 0.23[0.12]a | |
Premature birth | 0.39[0.06]c | 0.39[0.06]c | −0.02[0.07] | −0.01[0.07] | 0.31[0.04]c | 0.31[0.04]c | |
Lung cancer | 0.54[0.12]c | 0.60[0.12]c | 0.38[0.17]a | 0.40[0.17]a | 0.55[0.12]c | 0.60[0.12]c | |
Heart attack | 0.12[0.05]a | 0.19[0.05]c | 0.53[0.06]c | 0.57[0.06]c | 0.19[0.04]c | 0.23[0.04]c | |
Addiction | −0.10[0.12] | −0.11[0.12] | 0.14[0.18] | 0.12[0.17] | −0.09[0.12] | −0.09[0.12] | |
Textual content | |||||||
Testimonial | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | |
Didactic | 0.36[0.03]c | 0.41[0.03]c | 0.23[0.04]c | 0.31[0.04]c | 0.22[0.03]c | 0.27[0.03]c | |
Interaction* | |||||||
Text X Education | 0.14[0.02]c | 0.08[0.03]b | 0.07[0.018]c | ||||
Low education stratum** | |||||||
Testimonial | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | |
Didactic | 0.03[0.11] | 0.13[0.07] | 0.10[0.08] | 0.15[0.05]b | 0.08[0.08] | 0.13[0.04]c | |
High education stratum** | |||||||
Testimonial | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | Ref. | Ref | |
Didactic | 0.33[0.08]c | 0.40[0.05]c | 0.49[0.06]c | 0.55[0.04]c | 0.30[0.06]c | 0.55[0.03]c |
p<0.05;
p<0.01;
p<0.001
adjusted model results include all variables shown in the table, except for the interaction coefficient. Adjusted models with interactions were estimated in a separate model that included all covariates (coefficients not shown).
results from analyses stratified by education level, with low education having technical, secondary education or lower, and high education having high school or higher. Adjusted models included the same variables described above (covariate coefficents not shown).