Table 1.
Climate change effect | Confidence in physical effect | Effect on fish | Plastic response | Potential evolutionary response | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
↑ Peak summer and fall temperatures | High | ↓ Parr survival | Seek cooler refugia | Heat tolerance | Bisson and Davis (1976), McCullough (1999), Crozier and Zabel (2006)* |
↑ or ↓ growth, depending on food supply and fish density | ↑ Energetic efficiency at high temperatures | Brett et al. (1982), ISAB, (2007) | |||
↑ Predation on juveniles | Predator avoidance behavior, choosing suboptimal habitat | Petersen and Kitchell (2001)*, Marine and Cech (2004) | |||
↓ Adult survival due to stress from temperature or disease | Migration delays, higher stray rate | Earlier adult migration ↑ Disease resistance ↑ Energetic efficiency at high temperatures | McCullough (1999), Hyatt et al. (2003), Naughton et al. (2005), Goniea et al. (2006), Battin et al. (2007) | ||
↓ Reproductive success (↓ egg viability from thermal stress, or smaller eggs due to ↑ energetic cost) | Shift reproductive allocation | McCullough (1999), Kinnison et al. (2001), Rand et al. (2006) | |||
↓ Summer and fall flows | High | ↓ Parr survival | Change habitat | Crozier and Zabel (2006)* | |
Shorter and milder winter | High | ↑ Development rates | Earlier emergence | ↑ Energetic efficiency at higher temperatures | Beacham and Murray (1989), Finstad et al. (2004) |
↑ Spring temperatures | High | ↑ Development rates | Earlier smolt migration | Beckman et al. (1998); Achord et al. (2007)* | |
↓ Smolt survival | ↑ Disease resistance earlier smolt migration ↑ Heat tolerance | Smith et al. (2003)* found no effect; Zabel et al. (in press)* negative effect | |||
Earlier spring freshet | High | Earlier smolt migration | Achord et al. (2007)* | ||
Weaker spring freshet | High | ↓ Smolt survival | Williams et al. (2005)*, Achord et al. (2007)* | ||
↓ Adult energetic cost (if not too hot) | Larger eggs | Kinnison et al. (2001), Rand et al. (2006) | |||
Delay in upwelling | Low | ↑ Juvenile survival if arrival time does not change | Logerwell et al. (2003), Scheuerell and Williams (2005)*, Williams et al. (2005)*, Zabel et al. (2006)*, Waples et al. (2008)*) | ||
↑ Ocean stratification ↑ Surface temperature | High | ↑ Metabolic costs in surface water | ↑ Vertical migration Shift locations | ↓ Metabolic rates Change migration route | Welch et al. (1998), Walker et al. (2000), Portner and Knust (2007) |
Acidification | High | ↓ Growth rate | Delayed maturation |
References with an * are specific to this population.