Skip to main content
. 2012 May 8;2012:983056. doi: 10.1155/2012/983056

Table 1.

Results of the main studies in artificial nutrition and hydration (ANH) in patients with severe dementia.

Study Objective and methodology Results Conclusion
Ciocon et al. [61] Evaluate the indications, benefits, and complications of ANH in patients using enteral tube, with serious swallowing disorders and at risk of aspiration 67% of patients were agitated when the tube was removed and 43% had aspiration pneumonia during the study Researchers concluded that the use of ANH may lead to a high frequency of complications

Finucane et al. [10] Review of the literature (1966 to 1999) to evaluate the use of ANH in advanced dementia No data to suggest that the use of ANH may prevent aspiration pneumonia, reduce the risk of infections or prolong life Most studies show that there are substantial risks in using ANH in these patients, and thus its use is discouraged

Li [62] Review the use of ANH in patients with advanced dementia ANH does not prevent malnutrition, reduce the occurrence of bed sores, or prevent aspiration pneumonia, nor does it prolong life Although it may not be effective in preventing malnutrition and dehydration, this type of feeding allows a degree of maintenance and patient comfort

Pasman et al. [19] Evaluate the discomfort of patients with serious dementia of a Dutch nursing home The highest rates of discomfort observed in these patients were in dyspnea, acute pain, and agitation Not choosing ANH did not correlate with the level of discomfort of the patients. ANH was identified as an individual decision

Clarfield et al. [63] Evaluate the use of ANH in patients with advanced dementia admitted to Israeli and Canadian hospitals in order to find the main differences between ethnicities and ethical issues 24,5% patients were in if fed by ANH These results may be explained by a combination of administrative or financial incentives and by religion and culture

Volkert et al. [43] ESPEN Guideline developed to recommend use of ONT or ANH in elderly patients based on scientific evidence No increase in survival associated with this use, leading the researchers to consider ANH only according to patient's or family's wishes ANH not recommended in patients with advanced dementia

Buiting et al. [64] To investigate the opinion of Dutch and Australian physicians on use of ANH in patients with advanced dementia Dutch physicians based their decision on a wide-ranging evaluation, while Australian physicians tended to use scientific evidence All are reluctant at beginning of ANH but Dutch physicians tend to take primary responsibility for the decision, while Australian physicians prefer to leave the decision to the family