Table 1. Clinical decision rules examined.
Patient and disease related factors | Episode specific factors | Rule formulation | Outcome | Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria | |
Klaassen [24] | None | Absolute monocyte count | Absolutely monocyte count >100/mm3 = low risk of bacteraemia | Significant bacterial infection | ANC <500cells/mm3 or ≤1000cells/mm3 and falling. Temperature >38.0°C ≥2 occasions in ≥12 h, or once >38.5°C, or localised infection | New malignant diagnosis; bone marrow or stem-cell transplantation in preceding 6 months. Another medical condition that independently required inpatient observation. Interstitial infiltrate or lobar consolidation on chest x-ray |
Alexander [28] | AML, Burkitts lymphoma, induction ALL, progressive disease, relapsed with marrow involvement | Hypotension, tachypnea/hypoxia <94%, new CXR changes, altered mental status, severe mucositis, vomiting or abdominal pain, focal infection, other clinical reason for in-patient treatment | Absence of any risk factor = low risk of serious medical complication | Significant adverse outcome | ANC ≤500/mm3, temperature >38.5°C. Outpatient status. | Post stem cell transplant |
Rondinelli [27] | 2 points for central venous catheter, 1 point for age >5 years | 4.5 points for clinical site of infection,2.5 points for no URTI, 1 point each for fever >38.5°C, hemoglobin ≤7 g/dL | Total score <6 = low risk of serious infectious complication | Serious infectious compllications | ANC <500cells/mm3 or ≤1000cells/mm3 and falling, temperature ≥37.8°C ≥3 occasions in ≥24 h, or once >38.0°C. First episode per patient (new or relapsed disease) | Second or subsequent episode. Episodes in progressive disease (<6 m from between completing therapy and relapse). History of BMT |
PINDA [26] | Relapsed leukaemia, chemotherapy within 7 days of episode | CRP ≥90 mg/dL, hypotension, platelets ≤50 G/L | Zero risk factors or only low platelets or only <7 days from chemotherapy = low risk of invasive bacterial infection | Invasive bacterial infection | ANC ≤500cells/mm3, axillary temperature ≥38.0°C ≥2 occasions 1 h apart, or once ≥38.5°C | Not reported |
Ammann [32] | Bone marrow involvement, central venous catheter, pre-B-cell leukemia | Absence of clinical signs of viral infection, CRP >50 mg/dL, white blood cell count <0.5 G/L, hemoglobin >10 g/dL | Three or fewer risk factors = low risk of significant infection | Significant infection | Age 1–18 y, episode following non-myleoablative chemotherapy, temperature >38.5°C or >38°C for >2 h, and ANC <500 cells/mm3 | High dose chemotherapy |
SPOG (Adverse events rule) [7] | Applied after 24 hours: 4 points for chemotherapy more intensive than ALL maintenance | Applied after 24 hours: 5 points for hemoglobin >90 g/L, 3 points each for white blood cell count <0.3 G/L, platelet <50 G/L, any adverse event occurred | Total score <9 = low risk of adverse FN outcome | Significant adverse outcome | Age 1–18 y, episode following non-myleoablative chemotherapy, temperature >38.5°C or >38°C for >2 h, and ANC <500 cells/mm3 | High dose chemotherapy |
SPOG (Bacteraemia rule) [18] | None | Applied after 24 hours: shaking chills ever observed, haemoglobin >90 g/L, platelet <50 G/L, any other need for IP treatment | No risk factors = low risk of bacteraemia presenting after 24 hours | Late bacteraemia (>24 h) | Age 1–18 y, episode following non-myleoablative chemotherapy, temperature >38.5°C or >38°C for >2 h, and ANC <500 cells/mm3 | High dose chemotherapy |
Hakim [16] | Score from cancer diagnosis: AML = 20, ALL/lymphoma = 7, Solids = 0 | Clinical presentation of serious unwell or toxic = 14, fever at presentation: ≥39°C = 11, ANC <100/mm3 = 10 points | Total score <24 = low risk of serious infection or sepsis | Serious infection or sepsis | Outpatient, temperature >38.3°C or >38°C for >1 h, and ANC <500 cells/mm3 | Inpatients, stem cell transplant recipients |
Hakim [16] | Score from cancer diagnosis: AML = 11, others = 0. Relapsed disease = 11. Non-white patient = 8 | Clinical presentation of serious unwell or toxic = 20 | Total score <20 = low risk of any medical complication | Any medical complication | Outpatient, temperature >38.3°C or >38°C for >1 h, and ANC <500 cells/mm3 | Inpatients, stem cell transplant recipients |
Delebarre [14] (abstract only) | 1 point for hematological malignancy, chemotherapy at high-risk of prolonged neutropenia, | 1 point for clinical signs of local infection, fever >39°C, white cell count <500/mm3 or monocytes <100/mm3 and procalcitonin >0.3 ng/ml. TWO points for severe sepsis. | High risk >1 point. | Severe infection | Unclear | Unclear |
Mian [15] (abstract only) | No clear rule – uses postive blood culture result and raised CRP | No clear rule | Intensive care admission | Unclear | Unclear | |
Badiei [17] | Platelets <20 g/dL, temperature ≥39°C, ANC <100/mm3, mucositis, abnormal CXR on presentation | Risk of infection greater with more risk factors: no single threshold applied | Life threatening infection | Outpatient, temperature >38.5°C or >38°C for >1 h, and ANC <500 cells/mm3 | BMT, Fever with new diagnosis, inpatient status |
AML = acute myeloid leukaemia; ANC = Absolute neutrophil count; BMT = bone marrow transplant; CXR = chest radiograph; CRP = C-reactive protein; PINDA = Programa Infantil Nacional de Drogas Antineoplásticas; SPOG = Swiss Pediatric Oncology Group; URTI = upper respiratory tract infection.