Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Psychol Methods. 2012 Feb 6;17(2):255–283. doi: 10.1037/a0026977

Table 4.

Estimated Variance Components for Different LST Models Applied to the Externalizing Problem Behavior Data (N = 294)

CCO UCO TCO OSpe Rel
CU
Child report time 1 .21 .02 a .23
Mother report time 1 .32 .02 a .34
Father report time 1 .34 .23 a .57
Child report Time 2 .18 .17 a .35
Mother report time 2 .36 .03 a .39
Father report time 2 .38 .03 a .41
Child report Time 3 .12 .04 a .16
Mother report time 3 .34 .13 a .48
Father report time 3 .39 .03 a .42

OM
Child report time 1 .21 .36 .56 .02 a .58
Mother report time 1 .32 .34 .66 .02 a .68
Father report time 1 .34 b .43 b .77 b .23 b 1.00 b
Child report Time 2 .18 .52 .70 .17 a .87
Mother report time 2 .36 .38 .74 .03 a .77
Father report time 2 .38 .27 .65 .03 a .68
Child report Time 3 .12 .41 .53 .04 a .57
Mother report time 3 .34 .29 .64 .13 a .77
Father report time 3 .39 .28 .67 .03 a .70

M − 1 c
Child report time 1 .56 .56 .02 a .58
Mother report time 1 .11 d .56 d .67 .01 a .68
Father report time 1 .09 d .65 d .74 .23 a .97
Child report Time 2 .70 d .70 .13 a .83
Mother report time 2 .10 d .64 d .74 .03 a .77
Father report time 2 .10 d .56 d .66 .03 a .69
Child report Time 3 .52 .52 .03 a .55
Mother report time 3 .07 d .57 d .64 .22 a .87
Father report time 3 .12 d .55 d .67 .02 a .70

IT
Child report time 1 .57 .03 a .60
Mother report time 1 .67 .02 a .68
Father report time 1 .73 .16 a .89
Child report Time 2 .70 .13 a .83
Mother report time 2 .74 .03 a .78
Father report time 2 .66 .03 a .69
Child report Time 3 .52 .03 a .56
Mother report time 3 .64 .15 a .79
Father report time 3 .68 .03 a .71

Note. NM = model with no method factors; CU = correlated uniqueness approach; OM = M orthogonal method factor approach; M − 1 = M − 1 correlated method factor approach; IT = indicator specific trait factor approach. CCO = common consistency; UCO = unique consistency; TCO = total consistency; OSpe = occasion-specificity; Rel = reliability. Sum scores of the Externalizing Problem Behavior Scale of the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL; Achenbach & Edelbrock, 1983) served as indicators. The model without method factors did not converge for these data.

a

the variances of all state residual factors were non-significant (p ≥ .28).

b

In this model, the residual variance of the father report indicator at time 1 was estimated to be zero.

c

Child report served as reference method in this model.

d

to be interpreted relative to the reference method (child report). Dashes indicate that a coefficient is not applicable. TCO and OSpe do not always add up to the reliability coefficient due to rounding errors.