Table 2. Participant characteristics.
STUDY | POPULATION | ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA | DRUGS | BASELINE LIPIDS (mmol/l) | |||
Gender, mean age, ethnicity | Mean BMI, Smokers | ART | LLM | TG | total cholesterol | ||
Omega 3 supplementation | |||||||
Peters 2012 | 98% men 45 yrs 90% white | BMI 24 | Fasting TG between 3.4–11.3 mmol/l on low cholesterol diet, avoiding excess alcohol | Stable ART >3 months 52% PIs 46% RTV | All on fibrate or niacin | 4.9 | 6.3 |
Thusgaard 2009 | 78% men 45 yrs 86% white | BMI 24.7 31% smokers | All patients on ART | >3 months ART 47% PIs | 8% | 1.67 | 5.45 |
Carter 2006 | 100% men48 yrs | BMI 24 | total cholesterol <6.5 mmol/l; TG 3.5–10 mmol/l | Stable ART >6 months82% PIs | 18% | 5.06 | 5.77 |
DeTruchis 2007 | 89% men 46 yrs | BMI 23 | TG ≥3.43 mmol/l + TG 2–10 g/l after 4 week TG lowering diet; glucose ≤6.6 mmol/l, alcohol ≤20 g/d | Stable ART ≥2 months72% PIs | Nil | 4.5 | NR |
Woods 2009 | 80% men 47 yrs* 50% white | BMI 25* | BMI 19–30+ TG >1.69 mmol/l or insulin resistance | 87% on ART 63%PIs 50% RTV | Nil | 2.01* | 5.08* |
Wohl 2005 | 90% men 44 yrs 46% white | BMI 27 | TG >2.26 mmol/l | Stable ART >3 months43% RTV | Yes %NR | 5.44 | 6.23 |
Baril 2007 | 98% men, 49 yrs, 95% white | 72% smokers (current or past) 14% DM | triglyceride 6–11 mmol/l, or triglyceride 2–6 mmol/l with total cholesterol:HDL-cholesterol ≥6 | Stable ART >6 months 60% PIs | 59% | 5 | 6.05 |
Peabody 2002§ | 75% men 42 yrs | BMI 25 | triglyceride >3 mmol/l | On ART | NR | 4.42 | 5.71 |
Gerber 2008 | 93% men 43 yrs* 57% white | triglyceride ≥4.5 mmol/l + LDL-cholesterol ≤4.1 mmol/lAdherence to lipid lowering diet and exercise for 28 d pre screening | ART >3 months 39% PIs | Nil | 7.54* | 6.33* | |
Dietary intervention | |||||||
Fitch 2006 | % NR 45 yrs,32% white, | BMI 32, 45% smokers | Metabolic syndrome = 3/5 of: raised triglyceride, WC, or BP, fasting glucose, low HDL-cholesterol | stable ART >1 month 53% PIs | 9% | 2.48 | 5.14 |
Sanchez 2006§ | 74% men 42 yrs | BMI 25 52% smokers | Lipodystrophy + no alcohol abuse + no Family History of dyslipidaemia | Stable ART >6 months | Nil | 2.62§ | 5.57§ |
Lazzaretti 2012 | 37% men 38 yrs | BMI 24 27% smokers | No ART, no LLM, no history of CVD/dyslipidaemia (mean CD4 177) | naïve to ART 19%started PIs | 3% started | 1.52 | 3.94§ |
Balasubramanyam 2011 | 91% men 45 yrs 38% white | BMI 27 62% Hx of smoking | Triglycerides between 1.7–11.3 mmol/l + BMI 19–35+ no LLM + CD4>100 | Stable ART >6 months 72% PIs | Nil | 3.62 | 5.63 |
Ng 2011 | 77% men 41 yrs 0% white | BMI 22 | Not previously received diet advice + stable with HIV diagnosis and no current illness(many newly diagnosed and not stable) | 79% on ART 17% PIs | Yes %NR | 1.99 | 4.69 |
Thanasilp 2010§ | 100% women | On ART | 100% on ART | ||||
Other tablet supplementation | |||||||
Hadigan 2006 | 74% men 46 yrs | BMI 27 | Lipodystrophy + triglyceride >1.69 mmol/l + no alcohol abuse | Stable ART >3 months 52% PIs | Nil | 2.99 | 5.23 |
Chow 2010 | 89% men 51 yrs* 53% white | BMI 25* 21% smokers 37% ex smokers | HDL-cholesterol <1.04 mmol/l + LDL-cholesterol <3.37 mmol/l | Stable ART ≥6 months 42% PIs | Nil | 1.76 | 4.67 |
Aghdassi 2010 | 96% men 48 yrs | BMI 26 33%smokers | One metabolic abnormality (raised glucose, triglyceride, total cholesterol or low HDL-cholesterol, self reported LD) + HOMA-IR >2.5 (fasting glucose x insulin) | Stable ART >3 months 65% PIs | 31% | 2.64 | 4.97 |
Characteristics of the eighteen studies included in the qualitative synthesis: Population, eligibility criteria, baseline lipid levels, use of antiretroviral and lipid lowering drugs.
NR = not recorded.
LLM = lipid modification medication.
ART = antiretroviral therapy.
PIs = protease inhibitors.
RTV = ritonavir.
BMI = body mass index.
DM = diabetic.
CVD = cardiovascular disease.
HOMA-IR = insulin resistance.
Conversion factor used: x 0.01129 for mg/dl to mmol/l.