Table 2.
Reference | Sample size | Age† | E.F. | Follow-up period | Transmission modality | NYHAa class | Study design | Place |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(1) Dendale et al. [21] | 160 | 76 ± 10 | 35 ± 15% | 6 m | Cell phone | >II | RCTb | 7 hospitals in Belgium |
(2) Wade et al. [22] | 316 | 78.1 | Not reported | 6 m | Internet link | Not reported | RCTb | New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania residents |
(3) Scherr et al. [23] | 120 | 66 (median, IQRc 62–72) | <38% | 6 m | Mobile phone | II–IV | RCTb | Austria |
(4) Mortara et al. [24] | 461 | 60 ± 11 | 29 ± 7 | 12 m | Telephone line | II–IV (2.4 ± 0.6) | RCTb | 11 centers in Italy, UK, and Poland |
(5) Dar et al. [25] | 182 | 72 (Mean) SDd: 12 | Not reported | 6 m | Telephone line | II–IV | RCTb | 3 acute hospitals in northwest London |
(6) Antonicelli et al. [26] | 57 | 78 (Mean) SDd: 7 | 12 m | Telephone line | II–IV | RCTb | Italy | |
(7) Cleland et al. [27] | 426 | 67 (Mean) SDd: 12 | <40% | 8 m | Telephone line | I–IV | RCTb | 16 hospitals in Germany, UK and The Netherlands |
(8) Giordano et al. [28] | 460 | 57 ± 10 | <40% | 12 m | Telephone line | II–IV | RCTb | 5 cardiovascular rehabilitation departments in Italy |
(9) Goldberg et al. [29] | 280 | 59 ± 15 | <35% | 6 m | Telephone line | III-IV | RCTb | 16 heart failure centres in the USA |
(10) Tompkins and Orwat [30] | 390 | 76.1 (SDd: 8.1) | Not reported | 6 m | Telephone line | Not reported | RCTb | Arizona, USA |
(11) Soran et al. [31] | 315 | 76 ± 7 | 23 ± 9% | 6 m | Telephone line | II-III | RCTb | 3 cites in Pittsburg, Cleveland, and Miami, USA |
(12) Koehler et al. [32] | 710 | 66.9 ± 10.7 | ≤35% | 26 m (median) | Cell phone | II-III | RCTb | 165 practices in Germany |
†Age is reported in years as a mean value unless otherwise stated.
aNYHA: New York Heart Association, bRCT: randomized controlled trial, cIQR: interquartile range, dSD: standard deviation.