Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Jun 14.
Published in final edited form as: J Phys Chem B. 2012 Mar 19;116(23):6781–6788. doi: 10.1021/jp212399g

Table 1.

Computed binding energies and energy components (kcal/mol) between acetic acid (A) and water (B) using iterative charge-updating optimization in multilevel X-Pol. The 6-31G(d) basis set is used in all calculations at the M06/MG3S optimized geometries.

A B ΔEdist
ΔEAint(B)
ΔEBint(A)
ΔEint ΔEba
X-Pol optimization by iteratively updating MK charges
M06 M06 1.4 −9.1 −7.8 −8.4 −7.0
M06 B3LYP 1.4 −8.9 −7.6 −8.2 −6.8
M06 HF 1.6 −9.4 −8.2 −8.8 −7.2
MP2 HF 1.2 −8.8 −7.8 −8.3 −7.1
CCSD M06 1.0 −8.7 −7.7 −8.2 −7.2
X-Pol optimization by iteratively updating MPA charges
M06 M06 1.5 −9.6 −8.7 −9.2 −7.7
M06 B3LYP 1.5 −9.2 −8.5 −8.8 −7.3
M06 HF 1.8 −10.2 −9.2 −9.7 −7.9
MP2 HF 1.3 −9.5 −8.4 −9.0 −7.7
CCSD M06 1.1 −9.1 −8.3 −8.7 −7.6
Full wave function calculation without fragmentation
M06b −6.9
CCSD(T)b −6.6
a

For the purposes of this table, the multilevel X-Pol calculations of ΔEb are set equal to ΔEele, that is, they include the change in intramonomer energy and the electrostatic interaction energy but not the intermonomer exchange repulsion and dispersion terms

b

Computed using the MG3S basis set at the M062X/MG3S geometries.